Seal product ban approved by EU

by albertacowpoke | July 27, 2009 at 04:35 am
208 views | 31 Recommendations | 6 comments

Videos

3_ Canadian Seal Hunt 2009

see larger video

sourced by albertacowpoke

3_ Canadian Seal Hunt 2009

Photos

Cute harp seal baby

Cute harp seal baby

see larger image

uploaded by travel_photography

In May the European Union passed a bill to ban the import of seal products by a vote of 550-49.  Today this bill has been approved by the EU member states, a move that the Canadian government said would be an unfair trade restriction.

This ban effectively put 6000 people out of a job, including remote northern inuit communities.

The bill was approved without debate in a meeting of EU Foreign Ministers.

Denmark and Romania abstained from voting on the ban, while Austria also abstained because it wanted stricter restrictions.

The ban applies to all products derived from seal, including fur, meat, oil blubber and even omega-3 pills made from seal oil.

The current ban exempts products derived from traditional seal hunts carried out by Inuits in Canada, Russia, Greenland and Alaska.

Another exemption would be to allow small scale seal hunts to allow management of populations.  The products derived from those hunts would not be allowed to enter the EU.

Yesterday Canada made a last minute appeal to the 27 member states of the EU to reconsider this decision.  Canada, in all likelihood, will appeal this decision with the WTO as an unfair trade restriction.

It is interesting to note that the EU recognizes that the seal population need to be managed.

The European Union has approved a ban on the import of seal products, a move that the Canadian government has said would be an unfair trade restriction.

The ban was approved without debate at a meeting of EU foreign ministers on Monday.

Demark and Romania abstained from backing the measure, which Ottawa has protested as an unfair trade restriction. Austria also abstained because it wants a stricter ban.

The restrictions would apply to all products and processed goods derived from seals, including fur, meat, oil blubber and even omega-3 pills made from seal oil. But the current ban exempts products from traditional hunts carried out by Inuit in Canada, Greenland, Alaska and Russia.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Paschen

The ban can not put the Inuit out of work since it does exempt them. There for traditional hunting has not been banned by the EU, only commercial hunting.

0
albertacowpoke

True enough, however they will not be able to sell any seal products since those are banned for import to the EU.

1
158

This is a difficult question.

Protection of wildlife vs protection of jobs.

0
albertacowpoke

Your question is absolutely a valid one, however the EU is recognizing that there has to be some culling because of the way seal reproduce.  The issue here is how the seal hunt is conducted.   It has been advertised as being cruel.

1
Some12squeeze

I wonder how the Western world would react if the greater Indian community put forward a bill to ban all beef produce on the grounds it was sacrilege? Maybe forcing us to eat our dogs? When will Governments learn to make educated decisions that are regulated to prevent cruelty  & abuse, but remaining progressive for the good of all those effected.  I think of myself as a conservationist but not with ignorance of those deserving their own freedom to progress. In the early 1980's, Australia's ' do-gooder's' had a bill passed to prevent the eradication of wild & diseased buffalo in Australia's Northern Territory due to it's imagined 'cruelty'. The buffalo were imported here by the chinese in the hope of growing rice in the wet season, but were later abandoned. They became quite dangerous in the wild. But rather than capture & humanely process the animals through a 'Vet' controlled abattoir as had been the practise for several years, the 'Greens' had the diseased animals shot from helicopters. Of course they were ignorant to how hard it is to kill a full grown moving target with bullets. Most were only wounded & left to be torn apart by crocodiles, dingos or wild pigs. Many were crippled & left to starve to death. Another bill was passed to protect crocodiles so they could be marketed to promote our amazing outback for the  tourism dollars. I am waiting on footage showing the masses of crocodiles waiting to greet those unsuspecting tourists. (To be posted shortly) When will these 'Greenies' realise that Governments pass bills to protect cute fluffy toy looking animals to distract you from the billions they waste on space research instead of channelling it towards real issues like health, housing & education. Billions of dollars are burnt off in our atmosphere while millions of people are starving to death. Thousands annually die from the common cold. Just as thousands have now died for a prizeless war. Our world would fare better if run by children. At least laughter would then be heard more often than tears.

0
albertacowpoke

Thank you for your comments.  The questions you raise are valid and so are your points.  Canada is appealing this decision and will take it to the WTO based on the fact that they believe the seal hunt has been given a bad rap.  They believe that the sealhunt is being conducted in a humane way and that the practices shown on videos is no longer used. 

I can't comment on the practices used as I haven't been there.  They were hacked to death at one point as they didn't want bullet holes in the fur, apparently now they shoot them.  I can't verify that though.

The issue is not the seals survival but the alleged cruelty in hunting them.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Paschen
First Flagged at 6:10 AM, Jul 27, 2009 by Paschen
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (31)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from