Sean Mulveyhill, Kayla Narey Charged in Phoebe Prince Suicide

The law needs to be blind and consistent. What I mean is that the law shouldnt take into consideration who you are etc. If you commit a crime then you commit a crime, the crime shouldnt be dealt with or treated any different in regard to ones race, gender etc. Im pretty sure that if a female was to harras a male student then there wouldnt be much of a reprecusion. Also it was noted that one kid is going to be charged for assault with a dangerous weapon for throwing a can( of soda?) at Phoebe. If he is charged for with assault with a d with throwing a can at phoebe then EVERY body else after him needs to be charged with same scrime for same act. Im not belittling what happened. My heart goes out to the girl as I hate bullies bit in order for this to be effective then we need consistencies, we need standards. In the military we always get briefed about new rules in which we sign after the brief agreeing to the fact that we were told and we always get tested our knowledge of the rules. Well before every single last one of these degenerate children even stepfoot into a class room they need to get a similar brief. The principal needs to say youre in  school here to learn, if you can respect the rights of another person then you are going to get put out. Three Strikes and your out. This behavior will not be tolerated.

i lol'd

This is by far one of the stupidest things i've ever read. Some girl kills herself because kids are teasing her and she had a can thrown at her? If shes so stupid and can't deal with her own problems properly then thats her fault. These six (or maybe nine) kids had nothing to do with her death in my opinion. They were simply being teenagers, teenagers will make fun of just about everyone. The kids who can't take the teasing and break down will be teased worse, the ones who show some backbone, ignore it, laugh it off or even make comments back will generally be passed on quickly. So her death is her fault for taking what other people thing far too seriously and generally being a crybaby for lack of a better term. The world as whole in fact take what others think or do way too seriously. Also, anyone who thinks these kids should face jail time, think of it this way. Have you yourself ever called someone a name, teased someone, threw something at someone, done anything purposely to get under anyone's skin? If so then if they go to jail, or face any punishment for that matter, then you should be right there along side of them. Plus, to the comment made about about it may be the "bullies" parents fault for raising "monsters". What about the girl's parents? Isn't it their responsibility to raise their child to be able to hand pressure, critisizm and the same teasing a 9 year old can do? Not to mention their responsibility to see when their child is going through harsh times and look into it and protect them? So if this is the teen's parents fault, it's also the girl's parents fault by that logic, which it's not. The only person at fault for her death is her. However, 99% of the people who read this will be far too retarded to fully comprehend it and will automatically assume "oh no hes wrong and just being an asshole." So hey, to each their own. I myself, will continue to look at this the way it truely is, one less whiny little kid who can't handle the pressures of the world, as harsh as that sounds.

i like how you guys remove comments not mourning the dead yet still making a valid point just cause it's not a point you agree with. You should meet my three year old nephew, you would get along.

Phoebe the attractive one. The girls who bullied her were ugly. No wonder their boyfriends like Phoebe and not them. All this was over worthless boys. If the guy cheat on you forget him hes a jerk. It so sad wheres their self-respect. Was punky boys worth fucking up their lives over and their future. Stupid jealous ungraceful bitches.

Phoebe the attractive one. The girls who bullied her were ugly. No wonder their boyfriends like Phoebe and not them. All this was over worthless boys. If the guy cheat on you forget him hes a jerk. It so sad wheres their self-respect. Was punky boys worth fucking up their lives over and their future. Stupid jealous ungraceful bitches.

I know how it feels for someone to break up you and your boyfriend out of jealously. One time the girl tried to steal my boyfriend out of jealously. She talked shit to me on myspace and over the phone. She called me the slut and the whore. Which didnt bother me because I knew she was jealous. She was probably just mad because she couldnt find anyone else who would go out with her. She was just as ugly as the girls who bullied Phoebe Prince. She look like Serena and Venus Williams(whos ugly)but she was short and had short curly hair and glasses. She is just like the girls who bullied Phoebe. She and them are a bunch of ugly jealous ungrateful bitches.

you are obviously very alone in this world. absolutely no one would ever agree with you. thats just pathetic. and you are right 99% of people wont agree with what you just wrote because it is absolutely ridiculous. you have an incredibly sick mind and the "pressures of the world" dont include people physically and emotionally beating you everyday. sorry your daddy must have not loved you when you were child, otherwise you would have some kind of heart and not think this way.

I agree with the above comment. Some people just isnt sensitive about others feelings. You obiviously wasnt bullied too much in school.

sorry i agree with hemgate to a point..life is tough..you need to be tough to get through it. its sad this girl thought her life was over just because of her classmates were being mean....and its equally sad her parents couldnt recognize her issues before she took her own life. high school is only a few short years..her mother should have transferred her or homeschooled her if she thought her child was being threatened. maybe the bullying was the cause..maybe there were more causes. cant find out now because she is dead. but none of those girls put the noose around her neck...unless anyone can prove they did.

hem gate (and others):I don't think that the average adult would disagree with the point that the world is tough and every individual needs to have some amount of resiliency in order to find happiness. That said, your assertion that "to each his own" is an appropriate way to view the actions of others is disturbing. First of all, read some research. The teenage brain (specifically the emotional processing and critical thinking - or as you wold say, problem solving portions of the brain) are not fully functional. Don't confuse the legal definition of "adult" with the brain's actual capabilities. Second, consider the magnitude of the situation. This girl was not simply "teased." At some point, most people experience teasing and in many cases teasing can provide learning opportunities and teachable moments for character development and growth, as you seem to sort of, in a very obscure and unfortunately disturbing way, understand. This was not TEASING. This was BULLYING. There is a difference in terms of the magnitude and force behind this behavior. Furthermore, there is a major difference between a single person teasing and a group attack that takes place over months. I am a teacher and by far the most disturbing thing to me is the lack of relationship and communication between the administrators, teachers, community members, and parents to identify these tendencies and teach students other ways to develop self-confidence, communication, and social skills. It seems to me that what starts as the typical behavior and response cycles of teens are not being molded into appropriate skills...possibly because we've put so many fears into teachers about speaking up when they see inappropriate behavior that doesn't specifically break rules but doesn't promote good citizenship. In any case, open your eyes. The world doesn't exist separate from us - we make the world the way we want it. And if you want bullying, that is your opinion, but I'd prefer a little more pleasant environment for my family.

Ummm - To the ignorant people who keep using the words "just" - It was a CRIME. You are the type of people that raise these inhuman heartless freaks - "I was just teasing" They don't understand boundaries or that other people besides them have Rights. The violated Phoebe's RIGHTS.Assault is threatening a person and is a crime.Battery is physically striking someone - metal cans count, especially when thrown from moving cars ( can traveling faster then the speed of the car - go fast enough you can kill someone)A 17 or 18 year old male manipulating a girl 14 or 15 into having sex with them is, in more intelligent states - a CRIME known as Statutory rape.Educate yourselves before you become the pathetic parent saying "She was just teasing, my daughter is a nice girl." because you weren't smart enough to teach your child that they are not the only ones with rights and that the law applies to them too.

I agree with the above poster.  This was criminal intent, criminal behavior. 

good. glad they are being indicted. they deserved everything that comes their way!

That Chanon Velasquez skum is the biggest piece of dirt of all of them. This arrogant little piece of garbage should pay for her crime. Hopefully her ugly face will be recognized throughout the world. Hopefully no one who sees this subhuman whore ever lets her forget how she totured and killed an innocent child.

Alot of people are seriously overeacting......Ok bullying is wrong but that's part of life sometimes....she was supposed to learn how to deal with it...also, why didn't her parents take interventions(Homeschool, transfer, or ect) if they knew she was so weak and being a victim...If anyone is to blame, it's prince's parents for not reconizing an issue, the bullying didn't kill her. She killed her.It's sad it ended that way but these students shouldn't be punished they didn't kill prince. Her parents, if they cared about her would've taken time to see how she felt and got her help before it was too late...I don't expect or think the students should have figured/cared that she was "SUICIDAL"...that's her "PARENTS JOB".Lots of teens could be victims but they stand firm or deal with it.....so because "ONE" decides to kill herself it's a crime...whatever..this is an angry mom trying to ruin other children's lives because she failed to protect her own child properly.Expelling, criminal charges, acting like others killed her....that is so wrong...these people need to open their eyes to who's really the murderer.....suicide is suicide....prince chose to be a victim and her parents supported that choice.