NP Rank:
Stephen Taylor created YouTube clip that Greens call Tory fake
An interesting story for the bloggers out there who think that they have free reign to post what they want or re-edit footage with a "creative" intent.
Controversy is brewing around a YouTube video that was promoted by bloggers and created by Conservative activist Stephen Taylor; and the Green Party is threatening to sue them all.
In the YouTube video Green Party leader Elizabeth May can be heard calling Canadians "stupid." Taylor promoted the audio as unedited to the blog The Tyee. The Tyee post was then picked up by popular site the Bourque Report. It spread on the web from there.
Taylor's claim that it the audio is unedited is the real problem. You don't need sophisticated equipment to tell that the audio attached to the video has been doctored. Had he promoted it as satire rather than truth, there may have been no controversy at all.
"It’s an attempt by the Conservatives through a front website to attack the credibility of Elizabeth May," Green spokesperson John Bennett told The Tyee. "They took what she said, cut it up, then put it back together."
But the man who made the video, Conservative political activist Stephen Taylor, denied doctoring the tape.
"I produced the video," Taylor told The Tyee in an e-mail. "The audio is taken unedited from an episode of TVO's The Agenda."
“You can go to TVO website, you can compare the time frames," Taylor said in a telephone interview. "The audio is undoctored."
Green spokesman Bennett insisted the tape was spliced, and threatened legal action.
"Stephen Taylor is a surrogate for the Conservative Party," Bennett told The Tyee. "We're considering legal action. TVO is considering legal action as well."
Bennett said the Tories leaked the video anonymously through a blog website so that they could deny any hand in its creation.
"The Conservative Party has nothing to do with this production. I’m acting independently as someone who wants to see them elected," Taylor said.
Conservative spokesperson Mike Storeshaw also said the party was not involved.
“(May’s) representative should take off the tinfoil hat and join us in the real world,” Storeshaw told The Tyee. “We’re not in the business of making staged videos.”
In the disputed clip, May appears to say: “I think Canadians are stupid… I fundamentally agree with that assessment."
I have to wonder why the Conservatives would bother to target May in this way; she is not the biggest threat to the Tory campaign. My instincts tell me Taylor really did act alone.




Comments (0)