Suicide: Desensitization and the "Doctrine of Can't"

by Grace H | October 24, 2009 at 02:26 pm
210 views | 26 Recommendations | 6 comments


            For the fourth time in a little more than four months a student attending California's Palo Alto High School has committed suicide. The most recent occurrence was carried out by jumping in front of a train. This tragedy is simply a microcosm of an alarming epidemic—that after years of steady decline, suicides by youth ages 10-19 years are again on the rise.



            Any myriad of a variety of externalities could be cited as contributing to this calamity. Two often overlooked major factors include the desensitization of death and the "Doctrine of Can't."



            Death surrounds us. It is the headline of the morning paper and the main story of the six-o-clock news. A loss of life is a loss of life—be it due to the conflicts in the Middle East or the actions of a citizen back home. Yes, death is a part of life and thus merits acceptance and overcoming. However, premature death is a not something that should be received so readily.



            The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and capital punishment are two controversial subjects that deal with death. I cannot tell you how many times I have heard “I’d rather the war be there than here at home,” or “better them than us,” uttered in absolute dispassionate ignorance. Loss of life may always be circumvented if not avoided altogether. Death is still death regardless if we mourn our friends and proclaim them martyrs, or celebrate the deaths of our enemies. This portrayal has been upheld by our culture and is still particularly evident in our modern media.



            The existence of capital punishment is at fault. Here and now I will not digress into fully discussing its merits and demerits. The mob is always ready to jump to vigilante action whenever they perceive a slight. However, as humans with rational minds clouded by emotion there is no way we can truly judge who deserves such a fate. How many times in a day do we say “I’m gonna kill so-and-so” for whatever frivolity they have done to us, but do not mean it?  Death is viewed so apathetically that we should not have the arrogance to even attempt to judge let alone condemn another human being to death.



“Many that live deserve death. And some die that deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then be not too eager to deal out death in the name of justice, fearing for your own safety. Even the wise cannot see all ends.” – J. R. R. Tolkien (The Lord of the Rings).



            Violence begets violence, hate begets hate, and death begets death. All things begotten are begotten exponentially.



            Death has fallen into the mundane. It no longer carries the same weight and shock that it had in the past. Therefore, not enough is done to prevent it on any front. Suicide is the saddest of all deaths. It is brought on by utter rejection from society and dissatisfaction with the state of being of the soul. It is a resultant of the way we are treated and what is said to us.



            The “Doctrine of Can’t” runs prevalent and unchecked throughout society. In our attempt to define ourselves we often devalue others. Everyday we are told what we can’t possibly do—statements which are in direct violation of the adage “Man can do anything he sets his mind to.” This “Doctrine” is instilled into our youth in every facet of their lives.



            Youth go to school were teachers and administrators tell them they can’t amount to anything other than the potential assigned to them. Never mind the fact that students have proven these people wrong and gone off to achieve greatness and world renown. The perfect example of such is Albert Einstein—a man whose profound body of work is now taught in schools.



            Youth go to church where they are told they can’t drink, do drugs, or have sex. Yet these institutions do not give them a reason other than “you’ll go to Hell;” thereby setting the youth up for failure. Never mind that partaking in those activities has emotional consequences for the here and now, instead of some far out abstracted place. All in all drinking, drugs, and sex may lead to further dejection and a vicious downward spiral.



            Youths are told by their parents (who were told by their own parents) that they can’t do something “because I said so.” Never mind that this idiotic response does nothing but lead to the action being done anyway. By far, humans are rational and empathetic beings and such should always be appealed to in lieu of being shut down by hollow words.



            Youth of each generation are told by the previous generations (who were told by those before them) that they can’t plausibly be anything but “degenerates,” “good-for-nothings,” and “blights upon society.” Never mind that each generation, having been told this, grows up to become the innovators and world leaders of tomorrow. In the end, society has been upheld by generations of so-called hoodlums and spoiled brats.



“Almost everything that is great has been done by youth.” – Benjamin Disraeli.



            Rejection and dejection leads to bitterness. Bitterness to angry desperation. It is desperation that leads to all human ills. Suicide is one of the worst ends in that it is the most easily preventable yet in the same moment the most often not prevented. More can and must be done to eradicate this affliction from the face of the planet.



            There is no justification in the natural or supernatural that can explain away the allowance of suicide. Wake up and pay attention to those next to you—to those on your right, and those on your left—for it is highly likely one if not both of them have contemplated suicide or is doing so at this very instance. Society must refrain from letting its members slip through the cracks in the floorboard. Treat those in your immediate environment with respect and dignity, with gentleness and kindness, and above all with love. Just by doing so, who knows, you might be saving a life.





        




recommend Add a comment
0
Amy Judd

Good opinion piece, thanks for sharing it.

0
a211423

http://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pub/PreventingSuicide.html

I am sorry to hear of this in Palo Alto, for it seems like four children in four months is beyond the average. 

I have given a link to the CDC brochure for Suicide Prevention.  What to look for and signs that someone you love might be contemplating suicide.

0
Rhonda J Mangus

Thank you for an interesting Opinion piece, Grace H.

Death by suicide is truly an unfortunate demise. It is the third leading cause of death for young people in the United States, ages 10-24. 

Preventing suicide is probably one of life's more challenging and heart-wrenching efforts -- thanks again.





0
angelica d'archangelis

The children in Europe are also suffering and this has been traced to the digital tv signal.  Please pass this info on.Adverse Health Effects From The Operation of Digital Broadcast Television Stations (DVB-T)

0
Grace H

While it is probable that such a trace can and has been made, that is not the overarching root of the problem. It is just another externality. Regarless, this is an issue that must be addressed.

1
everchanging

We as people need to listen to our youths, elders and everyone in between. Maybe we think they (this or that person) are just having a moment and they will be ok or they will get over it, or they need to be strong, buck up or what ever. Yet here is the hard cold reality of life right before you, someone who you know or talk to or even live with is thinking for what ever reason that life is not important and wants a way out, even while they are telling you, you still do not believe what is said or you've heard it all before. Please do not walk away or say I have this or that and I will be late, because when it is all said and done - the if and why will continully make you question yourself had I only stayed and called in or rescheduled.

Well, now there gone (whom ever it was) and you can not see them, hear them, hold them, thank them, joke with them, laugh or cry with them any more and least of all replace them, even though you still love them and miss them, you can not change back the hands of time to prevent what has happened - its a cold, ugly, ruthless, heartless reality. Some may say it is a selfless act - but so is breathing to others.

Grace H has it right "Society must refrain from letting its members slip through the cracks in the floorboard. Treat those in your immediate environment with respect and dignity, with gentleness and kindness, and above all with love. Just by doing so, who knows, you might be saving a life."

Here are some sites and numbers for anyone who needs and wants help to live for another day and for those that know someone who has lost someone seek counseling for your own sanity and take a friend or someone close along with you "everyone needs someone to hold onto" while going through the healing process, do not be alone. 

Seek help via links and nmbers below

Call 1-800-273-talk (8255) English

1-888-628-9454 en español (Para información en español haga)

1-800-799-4TTY (4889) For Hearing and Speech Impaired with TTY Equipment 

National Suicide Prevention lifeline (24 hour a day 7 day a week 365 days a year)

American Association of Suicidology (aka AAS) and if you thinking of or considering  suicide Read this

Locator by state or zip code (it helpful to other that out of the area you are located)

CDC Suicide prevention page: lists of downloads (PDF files, Scientific Information and Statistics)  

Locator by state or zip code (it helpful to other that out of the area you are located)

People care enough to listen to others and reach out to other a hand to hold on to or better yet a should to cry on - just to not walk away from someone because you do not have the time, when in reality all we have is time.

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Amy Judd
First Flagged at 2:45 PM, Oct 24, 2009 by Amy Judd

Related Stories

Recommendations (26)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from