There is a Storm Brewing Part I

by tikun | July 27, 2009 at 03:34 am
401 views | 40 Recommendations | 26 comments

I have tried to share my account of the politcal dynamic that brews in this part of the Middle East. This is part one of a two part article that I have been working on of late. Enjoy.

There is a storm brewing and we are all waiting, wondering where and when it will begin and how it will all turn out. This event is not some small insignificant affair. It ultimately will decide the fate of all man/woman kind.

In my small corner of the planet there is a continuous battle for a piece of land that we Jews have been living on continuously since biblical times. Recent genetic testing appears to have supported this narrative. Some so-called Palestinians have actually come forward anonymously and admitted that their ancestors were Jewish and were forcefully converted during Turkish rule. They were given the choice to leave or become Muslim. It is an interesting twist to an already complex scenario that has no easy answers but many questions as yet unanswered.

There is no quick fix to the variety of attitudes that both sides maintain in light of all the distrust that both sides share. This distrust is also complex in and of itself. More often then not it is embedded with a fanatical religious insistence of all or nothing.
To be fair, while these voices cry louder then others it is still a minority voice that has been used by the media for ratings affect. This has muffled the sounds of reason by certainly the majority of Israelis and many Palestinians.

This is not by chance that the opera and its dramatic staged performance is dragging all of us along for the ride. Aside from all the he-said-she-said game play, Jews now have a home where we can once again be ourselves without apology or suspicion. However, the problem of being ourselves is not a simple one as many would think. It has been far too long since we ruled ourselves and that through a king. A poor choice warned the prophets.

In the sixty plus years of governance we still struggle to find a political system that effectively works as the needs and the population changes. We still suffer from the lag of cultural change it takes any society in order to adapt to the new status quo. One of the major challenges we obviously find our selves facing since 1967 takeover of the West Bank from Jordon and the Gaza Strip from the Egyptians is the desire by some to inhabit what was truly a part of ancient Israel that even today houses places of great social and religious significance to Jews along side the former Jordanian and Egyptian populations that also inhabit both areas.

I will not argue we belong here more then anyone else. First it is a useless effort and second it is irrelevant considering we are already a Jewish State. Facts on the ground created out of a moment in time that was ripe for Jews to once again decide their own fate as a people and nation. Fairness plays little in this narrative. There is only so much land in the world. No two people can stand on the same point. However, there is room for sharing with partners willing to acknowledge the others rights to be here. This is where the problem begins.

If the rest of the world governments would have stayed out of the situation I believe this two state solution would have been resolved. However, the unwillingness of the Muslim countries to accept the Jewish State prevents any further progress. The agenda of many Muslim leaders was for Islamic domination as it had so successfully achieved in previous eras throughout much of the world. With Islam being beaten back by the Turks and the Europeans the retreat was seen as a humiliation and defeat. The shame was just too much.. Now Israel exists as a nation and is flourishing in a region where governments/kingdoms have continuously oppressed their populations from thriving and manifesting their rights as free human beings. The Israeli success was just more fuel to the fire of shame and jealousy.

The European communities were recovering from a major devastation and were complicit in premeditated efforts to destroy the entire European Jewish population and blot them out of history. Directly and indirectly complicit in the heinous of crimes: Genocide.

Israel now a strong and proud people with a religious/cultural tradition that dates back thousands of years has the ability to rule over their own lives and to rule over the lives of others as a result of war. This was the perfect excuse for Europeans to absolve themselves of any burden of guilt they may still have had regarding the massacre of six million Jews by accusing the Jews of being the Nazis. This narrative worked just fine for the Palestinian leadership. They essentially got the wink from the Europeans to do what they needed to do, including terror attacks, in order to get rid of the Jews. The European religious mantra that the Jews were the Christ killers and deserve to die didn’t help the situation. It works for Europe and works fine for the Muslims in the region. By the way all of these countries excluding Egypt were artificially created out of European political expediency.

Israel in 2009 is a strong, creative, athletic, industrious country with a minority of non Jews that are also reaping the benefits of Israeli success. This is in spite of the Arab leadership in Israel constantly encouraging a hostile fifth column mentality. This reinforces a lack of trust that makes it difficult to fully secure all our citizens with life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

This kind of leadership by the Arab members of the Knesset through out Israel’s history has lent itself to relegating this “hostile” population to a begrudging equal status under the law. To be fair there is a significant part of the non-Jewish population that participates in all avenues of Israeli life and is quite integrated in the Israeli milieu with out giving up their own unique traditions. We have so much more to attain for all of our citizens but the road is clearly paved toward success. We have no other choice.

Today the pressure is on to find a solution to a problem that has been used by all sides as an excuse for hostility. This only postpones a solution for a Palestinian State and encourages the Palestinian leadership from recognizing Israel as a Jewish State that has a right to exist in the region.

This simple act will be the beginning of a trust that can only develop into a partnership for peace. Until the Arabs admit and accept Israel as a legitimate player in the region there will never to a Palestinian State. Not because of Israel, but as a result of Palestinian and Islamic forces unwillingness to embrace their brothers and open up their populations to the riches and talent that all Israelis will be more then willing to share with our Arab neighbors.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
3
albertacowpoke

Thank you for this article Tikun.  You explained the situation quite well. 

2
Hiranya Malwatta

Thanks for this, I hope the best for your country !

0
tikun

Thank You Hiranya.  It is much appreciated.

8
Paschen

Tikun, this is the usual rettoric from Israel trying to find excuses for not allowing a Palestinian state and justifying its politics.

If Israel has the right to exist then so does Palestine. The Arabs have accepted that a long time ago. What else now? Every time the Arabs make a concession and accept or meet a demand from the US or Israel ten new once follow. 

Enough is enough. No more excuses. The World has tolerated this game long enough. It is time for Israel to play fair and meet the demands from Palestine now.

61 year has been long enough for any form of oppression and occupation.

Or do you want for the Palestinian to establish a state of Palestine the way Israel established it self?

0
tikun

Thank you Moonwolf and Paschen for sharing your opinion on my opinion piece.


I have decided that you both have this conspiracy angle attached to anything I might say living in Israel. I respect Moonwolf's distrust and paranoia regarding my comments. If only I was as clever as he believes as a co-conspirator of some matrix revealed.

Paschen, this is not the "usual rhetoric". This is my opinion that you have every right to disagree with. Your anger reveals more then the words do.

3
rng

This is my opinion..
Which absolutely your right and privilege. However, the article is not marked as an opinion piece. I suspect there would be less concern if you did label it correctly

1
tikun

Thank You rng. My opinion is of course in the article but much of what is written is fact and not new information. This is just part I of a survey of the present sirtuation.

7
rng

much of what is written is fact

Most of the information presented as fact  is not universally accepted as fact: it is open to debate, both by historians, scholars and regional observers. I would contest that the article absent an opinion tag is a little misleading, and that on such a contentious matter that if you positioned it as an opinion piece it would  actually strengthen your position and create a greater potential for a more empathetic reading. Presenting it as if uncontested fact, makes it appear a propaganda piece rather than an valuable insight to support one side of a complex debate...IMHO

1
Paschen

I am not certain where you get anger here Tikun, I would not try to tell people what they think or what their sentiments are.

I am not any more angry at Israel then I would be at any other injustice, only in the case of Israel I have given up hope by now for a peaceful solution and future. 

Unfortunately some can not learn not evolve. so it seems. And this would be true for both sides in this conflict. You are in the US as a US Citizen by the way and this most of the time.

0
tikun

Sorry Uwe, But my time is spent almost always overseas. 99.9% currently.

5
rng

If there was ever a story that required an "Opinion" tag under NP rules - this would be it. This is an opinion piece defined.

0
QueensHart

Thank You Tikun for your article!  I disagree that this is  totally an opinion piece Sir.

This is informative for people who are unaware of the history, spiritual, psychological

and physical points are here.

QH : )

5
rng

Then I would recommend a reading of a balanced history. That way you can learn the facts and make an informed decision as to which side of the debate you would want to support. If you do not know how the facts, how can you ever determine what is an opinion and what is not?

1
lalith

Good one, Tikun. Thanks.

0
tikun

Thanks QueenHart and Lalith for your comments.

0
marianmo

thank you for this story...

3
Rory Cripps

In the immortal words of that great American, Rodney King: Why can't we all just get along? I, like many Americans, don't know a hell of a lot about the basis for the continued strife between the Israelis  and the Palestinians.. I only know what I've read in the history books and the newspapers . . . and y'all know how that goes. What are considered and accepted as facts, at one point, often turn out to be nothing but opinions after close scrutiny. The only solid things that I have to go on are these:  The Jewish people, throughout the centuries, have always been a tiny but tenacious minority--survivors if you will.  Indeed they managed to survive, and  thrive, and retain their identity throughout the centuries, whereas other groups, faced with similar circumstances, perhaps, would have given up and blended into the crowd, as it were, solely for the purpose of survival. And throughout much of their history, the Jews were not only continuously (and often brutally) persecuted and confined to Ghettos,  but they faced a well-orchestrated/all out/almost successful effort dedicated to their literal extermination just three short generations ago.  Infants torn from their mother's breasts their heads smashed against walls; entire families thrown into ditches and machine-gunned; packed into trains, like cattle, delivered to slaughter houses . . . . This is sick stuff, but what's even sicker is that the world, at the time,  allowed it to happen. I'm not Jewish, but if I were, I'd be chronically  pissed off and I wouldn't budge an inch.

0
albertacowpoke

Well said Rory. 

0
tikun

Thanks so much for your comments Rory. Well said.

2
Barry Artiste

Excellent Story Tik, Controversial comments from the readers, show you da man!  Good Stuff!

1
albertacowpoke

Yep I.ll second that Barry

3
J2B

Am I right in thinking that most white Jews in Israel actually descend from Europe so could not have been living on the land since Bible times, and that the true Jews are blacks from Africa? Are you a white or black Jew?

I would also like to ask you, are both white and black Jews equal in Israel? Was Jesus a black Jew?

0
tikun

Thanks Barry and Karl for the comments.



5
J2B

In 1999, British Gas discovered huge natural gas fields, worth billions of dollars, in Palestinian territorial waters off the coast of Gaza. Israel has already built a horizontal pipeline to siphon off gas from at least one of these fields. If there is an unspoken reason for the siege of Gaza - this is it.

0
tikun

I think not "not verified". They found gas reserves off the Gaza coast and Israel off the Haifa coast. If you look at a map you will see how far away they are. You really need to refrain from wishful thinking and stick to the facts. please.


I was gong to answer your interesting previous question in spite of your "not verified" status but after this silly statement I will pull the plug.


0
tikun

Moonwolf,


The accusation was that Israel was siphoning off the gas deposits near Gaza by underground pipes from the discovery near Haifa. Not only is that not true but the articles you present here do  not even address this situation. That is what was presented in a comment on my article. nothing more.


2nd. the above articles  are opinion pieces about motives and tactics by Israel and the fight for resources. It is only an opinion. No facts just again accusations. 

Thanks for the attempt. But I actually read them all.


This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

albertacowpoke
First Flagged at 3:53 AM, Jul 27, 2009 by albertacowpoke

Related Stories

Recommendations (40)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from