Town tries to take pony away from disabled 3 year-old

by Jason Sanders | November 27, 2008 at 11:21 am
889 views | 18 Recommendations | 20 comments

Photos

Palomino Miniature Pony

Palomino Miniature Pony

see larger image

uploaded by chelsey

Sam Spiteri, a 3 year old with spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy, has enjoyed the company of his miniature pony, Emily, for most of his life; but, the town of Caledon may take away the boy's companion because of smell complaints from the neighbours.This has to be the worst possible publicity for a town, and one has to wonder what they were thinking when they entertained the idea of taking away the therapeutic animal.

Now, reading further into the story, there are bylaws and zoning issues that do need to be addressed when housing a pony on one acre lot for protection of the animal; but, the real injustice is that the initial smell complaint came from their neighbour who lives next to a COW FARM.



The town of Caledon may force a three-year-old boy with cerebral palsy to give up his miniature pony after a neighbour complained about the smell.

Sam Spiteri’s grandfather gave him the pony, Emily, after he was diagnosed with spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy shortly after birth. The boy can’t walk or crawl, and Emily is part of his therapy regime.

“When we take him off the pony he cries. Even if he’s tired he doesn’t want to leave her,’’ his mother, Antonia Spiteri, said today.

But at the end of July, the town notified the Spiteris the pony had to be removed due to the complaints.


recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Yuliya Talmazan

That is just so wrong.

1
niknok2007

This is just an unbelievable story. How much benefit is this pony giving this young child? Surely, this outweighs the opinions of the small minded minority.

1
Marksda1

Just awful - it's too often laws are used as an excuse for the petty...

0
julesnene

This is a very sad story and I thank you for letting us know. May this beautiful miniature pony brighten up the lives of many people who are touched by it. Thanks for selecting my photo. Julia H. Sumangil

0
ewjz31

I know what stinks and it isn't the pony: it's discrimination.

ewjz31 has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Kenneth Johnson

FWIW, I have communicated with the town of Caledon, expressing my disgust at this travesty.

I consider the administrators of this mindless burg swine, and so informed them.

This is simply so wrong, so disgusting.

0
skyoudes

We raise and sell German Shepherds out of European Imports. This is one of my families in Washington State that also raise Miniature Ponies & bought a male and female German Shepherd, this was the male. This was a new pony named Sara with Euro who was only about 7 months old in this picture. Our families that own our dogs are great at keeping in touch with updates, and this one was so cute. Miniature ponies are used even in convalescent homes and very good therapy, as are the German Shepherds in many cases that our families have used them with old & young people alike. If everyone owned an animal and learned how to care for one, this world would be a nicer place. That is what animals do, bring out the best in humans.

skyoudes has contributed a photo to this story.

0
skyoudes

I might add in the area of smell....a cow farm is much worse than one miniature pony. There are much worse smells that do not come from animals, cities have some very bad pollution and nasty smells. I would take the country smell over those city smells any day. I am sure they aren't near as unhealthy either! This is horrible that anyone would take a pet from a child that needs this for some happiness in his life. These people pushing this must not have any heart, or they would not be pushing something so rediculas!

0
Cafegurl

I cant believe that they would do that! That horse might be the only joy that kid has and no one should be allowed to take that away....

0
DelorisKaren

That is horrible that they would want to take a pony away from any child who is special needs! This photo was of my neighbors sweet miniature pony they had bought for their two little girls. I never smelled any foul oder from this pony and it was well taken care of. Obviously the neighbor who is pursuing this has no compassion whatsoever. We need less of these type of people in the world.

0
anjiedoodles

I have seen the amazing results that can be produced from disabled children having access to animals, especially horses, for therapy. The RDA (riding for the disabled) here does fantastic work and it saddens me to read this article. Many disabled children have a special connection with animals and for the authorities in this case, to even consider the removal of someones animal, due to its 'smell' is ridiculous! To me, this sounds like a problem between neighbours, not a problem for any other reason. Unless there are serious issue over the upkeep of the pony, ie. dung not being removed from the paddock etc, then the chances of this animal 'smelling' are pretty slim. I know this as i am a horse owner myself. I own a miniature shetland and know that as they are so small...they cant produce enough dung to cause a stink! I hope that the town of Caledon, see sense.

0
bryanilona

How much smell  can you get from a miniature pony? That is such a heartless story. The people of that town should be organising a rota to help care for the pony and offer practical help for the family.

The dung should be a bonus for feeding rosebeds and highly sought after!


0
Donnaphoto

Animals in general (often dogs and horses, esp. miniature horses) are very therapeutic.  The bond and connection from these animals to someone who is emotionally and/or physically disabled is an amazing thing.  It's something near miraculous to those who can see and feel the connection they make with one another.  It's as if the animal knows instinctively they are needed to help out; to give a sense of love, comfort, strength, confidence and as I mentioned, bonding.  These gifts given by the animal, dog, or horse, are what keep the disabled or impaired persons' spirit alive; it gives them a purpose, something to look forward to, something that is not 'difficult' to do, adding to their daily trials.  It keeps hope and will alive inside. 

Caledon should be ashamed, and the neighbor who has filed the complaint should be even more ashamed.  How tragic our world has come when we cannot live peacefully amongst our own neighbors, find ways to solve issues and help one another.  It is this very concept that is shredding the fabric of "America" right out from under us.  I am sorry to hear about this and I pray for the 3 year old who needs this comfort in his life.

Thanks for bringing this to light and I hope legally the family can find a way to keep the horse.  Here's a web site I found relating to miniature horses being recognized for 'healing' and therapeutice benefits that also includes some law cases.  http://www.guidehorse.org/law_n_news.htm

Good Luck

0
pink_paints

This is just so wrong. This child is certainly benefiting from this miniature horse much more then the neighbors are hurting from the smell. How cruel they must be to try and take away something that probably makes that kid's day! Feel free to use any of my photos as well as request more, I have plenty of mini's to take pictures of. Thank you for selecting those of mine.

0
Mav_Fan

This is wrong, just wrong.  Hopefully an indignant uproar will make the people in charge realize that a cow farm is far smellier than one miniature pony which is performing a vital service, and  most likely an irreplaceable one as well.

0
emma_pollitt

pepper, my wee miniature horse cross. very sweet!

emma_pollitt has contributed a photo to this story.

0
hamaad

This is a sad thing to happen to the boy. This is really awful! poor boy must be really sad!!

0
AllenandBea

This miniature pony is at a farm called Avila Valley Barn. Children can feed it food that is given for free at the Barn store.

AllenandBea has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Tina Kells

Looks like he'll get to keep his pony!!!!  Thank you for small favours!

A Caledon, Ont., family is celebrating after the town ruled it can keep a miniature pony purchased for their son, who has cerebral palsy.

The Spiteri family gained worldwide attention after a neighbour complained it was violating a town bylaw by having the pony, Emily.

Three-year-old Sam has been riding Emily since he was an infant.

Sam was born with a form of cerebral palsy that makes it difficult for him to do ordinary tasks such as walk, hold toys, eat or speak.

He's so attached to the pony, said his mother Antonia Spiteri, that his rides usually end in tears because he doesn't want to leave Emily.

"Where healthy children have running and play, all the carefree happiness of a normal childhood, my son has his horse," she told the town's committee of adjustment.

But the Town of Caledon received a complaint from a neighbour who said Emily's smell is offensive.

The bylaw enforcement manager ruled the Spiteris' half-hectare property is zoned rural-residential, which means they cannot keep livestock.

But the Spiteris argued Emily shouldn't be classified as livestock because she was bought as a form of therapy.

Sam also has seizures, making it almost impossible to take him on long car trips to a riding facility elsewhere, which is why his grandfather bought him Emily.



0
★po3tic_po3t★

This picture was taken last year, 2007, in Owasso, Oklahoma at our Annual Christmas Parade on Main Street.

★po3tic_po3t★ has contributed a photo to this story.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

niknok2007
First Flagged at 2:18 PM, Nov 27, 2008 by niknok2007
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (18)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from