NP Rank:
Uncle Tom is Barack
First of all, I have been asked to edit the spelling of Barak, to Barack. Who else never noticed the spelling? Until it was pointed out, I never noticed it. Also, I got a lot of response about the Uncle Tom references. In my opinion, Obama did not become an Uncle Tom until he gained a position of world leadership by eliciting trust, then failing to represent the people who were all victims of American policy. Obama went off on his own leaving us all behind.
Yes, a white leader can do the same thing. Obama's entire political base were people, black and white, who thought he represented the African experience in America, and that he would stand up for human rights. What does he think, that the average American has the intellect of a critical thinking professor? We are the great unwashed, we're Joe 6-pak out here, we expect leadership and not to read that the President is ignoring human rights violations.
A lot of comments were about accounting for all the human rights violations that were ever committed by American corporations. That argument is like telling a cop not to give out tickets to people who run the red light, because everybody all over town are running red lights. Here's the original article before edit:
Ever since the release of the torture documents in the United States and Barak Obama's utter refusal to prosecute the perpetrators, Obama has been heavily criticized by his own supporters in the media. The combined opinion of Obama's actions was summed up by notables such as Tom Hartman and President Reagan's son Mike Reagan, as they expected more from the Obama Presidency.
We all did. All of us who pasted bumper stickers on our cars, and dropped dollar bills in fishbowls, and registered voters and walked precincts, expected more. Then my subconscious suggested that we may have really run across this personality dysfunction before and no person so far has the where with all to express it openly. Perhaps Harriet Beacher Stowe described this character best, as reiterated by Wikipedia:
Uncle Tom is a pejorative term for an African American who is perceived by others as behaving in a subservient manner to white American authority figures, or as seeking ingratiation with them by way of unnecessary accommodation. The term "Uncle Tom" comes from the title character of Harriet Beecher Stowe's novel Uncle Tom's Cabin. Critical and popular views of both the character and the novel have shifted over time.[1]
The Uncle Tom character was originally a Christian martyr, morally superior to his white owners in an antebellum fiction whose subtext was an argument that the institution of slavery was immoral. Numerous adaptations altered the depiction substantially, often rendering him feeble, servile, or a race traitor. These adaptations, along with critical distaste for the original character's passivity, contributed to the strongly negative connotations of the name in modern popular use.
When the majority of white America lines up behind a man of African descent, that says something more than "Hope." That says we're sick of the white establishment and intolerant of all the sins of the past, and we need someone to step up to the plate and get a backbone, and end what all of us hate.
NowPublic on Facebook
Recommendations (14)
-
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke
Redwater, Alberta, Canada -
Rhonda J Mangus
North Tonawanda, New York, United States -
djermano
Somewherein, China


Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (9)
at 20:34 on April 17th, 2009
And now that we have a black American President means it will be more difficult to criticize or level impeachment actions, because of racial discrimination allegations. As Clarence Thomas once said...."it's nothing but a high tech. lynching."
So let's keep reminding Mr. Obama his lying words.....of change....
Rev. Jermano
at 21:04 on April 17th, 2009
I have no problem whatsoever criticizing Mr. Obama. I come from a much different perspective than most. I worked for Harvard attorneys for 20 years, from all over the world, and I know the level of expectation from the best attorneys in America. There is simply no excuse for not prosecuting these people. None. I saw these same attorneys prosecute some of the worst white collar criminals without even blinking.
The only reason he is backing off is because he kept that ridiculous Secretary of Defense and he's entirely intimidated by the Pentagon. He has never been in the military, he has no heavy litigation experience, he was never a prosecutor, and he doesn't have the stomach for what it really takes.
He thought he could be President. So, let him be President. He needs to buck up and swallow it.
at 02:29 on April 18th, 2009
Interesting perspective presented in your article, but I don't think the unwillingness to prosecute "higher-ups" for crimes against prisoners is anything new or surprising. If you worked for a long time with Harvard lawyers and do not know that, then you are like I was. I also worked with attorneys for many years and believed that there was only one set of laws that applied to everyone. That is what comes of being raised on slogans like "we the people" and "liberty and justice for all." One might go through life, as I did for 50 years, believing the slogans without coming face to face with the naked truth. Some of the petitioners who are helping my family beg the USDOJ to please do its job and investigate the secret arrest and wrongful death of my mentally and physically handicapped brother, Larry Neal, discovered the truth about these slogans long before I did. They ring true as long as they are never tested.
My family's ordeal trying for nearly six years to get records and accountability after the secret arrest and wrongful death of our weakest member, an American citizen, and the refusal to hold anyone accountable for the abuse of prisoners in American custody are tests that reveal a horrifying truth: the law is not equally applied, never has been, probably never will be, and moreover, it may never have been intended to do so. See our futile efforts in this article:
New World Order Nullifies Constitutional Rights for Neal Family
http://www.care2.com/c2c/share/detail/1019414
One attorney I hoped would represent us against The Cochran Firm for defrauding my 80+ year old mom and actually working for the jail behind our back told me plainly that regardless of how good our case was, the laws in America were never intended to hold powerful people responsible to doing right by the powerless. They are used only in the reverse. Therefore, this refusal to hold the elite to any ethical standards and possibly subject them to imprisonment as criminals is not an Obama thang - it is the American way, established long before any of us were born.
Another fallacy in your article seems to be that you think it is racial. It is not. Obama's decision would be the same regardless of his race. While the average citizen is concentrating on race, the real issue in America is the same as in India - justice in America, or the lack thereof, is more a matter of socio-economic class distinctions. It just so happens that more blacks than whites are omitted from the "protected class" level due to our lack of wealth. Most of our forefathers never owned slaves to build us great wealth, and while others were free to stake claims to thousands of acres of free land, we were not. Catch-up with those kinds of economic advantages will never happen, regardless of MLK's mountaintop vision about blacks in the Promised Land.
In bygone years, the truth about unequal justice was tolerated and oftentimes applauded because it applied mainly to ethnic citizens. Lately, that is changing. America is broke and the concentration camps are almost ready, so there is less reason to hide the realities about who matters and who does not.
Blessings
at 02:54 on April 18th, 2009
This story line, along with the comments are definitely an interesting perspectives. If you let the worm out of the box to go after the Bush admininstration, how far back do you go with the prosecutions, i.e. the use of hydrogen bombs on Japan, bombings of Dresden, Hamburg during WWII, use of agent orange in Vietnam, the list goes on and on. I think you get my point. Personally I don.t think this has to do with race or protection of the elite. It has more to do with legal opinions rendered on methods of interrogation. I think we can all agree that torture will, in the long run, not provide good results. Most likely it will cause the opponent to seek revenge. (nothwithstanding that Al Quaida is already beheading their captives). Going on a witch hunt at this stage doesn.t make sense to me. How is waterboarding of one terrorists. a worse act than sending unmanned drones into Pakistan after high value targets and killing numerous civilians, including women and children in the consequential collateral damage, any different? Just food for thought.
at 07:13 on April 18th, 2009
I also post on allvoices.com and there are a bunch of people over there as well. I had to point out that the Uncle Tom character was also noted by Ralph Nader on U-tube and there are some other references floating around.
Tom is a vague character hard to detect, I had to use criteria before I was ready to make the call, because calling somebody an Uncle Tom is pretty awful. That is probably why Harriet Beacher Stowe was so successful in pointing out the neurotic psychological profile. People are complicated.
When you step up and offer yourself as President of the United States you are out there asking people to trust you. People are judged by their actions not their words, and during the election I just heard too many words to make me comfortable. I've had a long list of criteria going already. I didn't like the neuroticism and the all-too-neutral position on everything, the carefully constructed speech patterns, the clean crisp lines.
Then we found out it was a machine with a blueprint from it's inception. I also watch body language and I listen for speech pattern construction. People who enunciate beyond what is normal and cannot speak spontaneously, are hiding something. Maybe it's just truth upon truth, or maybe it's things they don't want known. I didn't like that he wasn't a spontaneous speaker.
I didn't like that he abandoned Rev. Wright. Rev. Wright didn't do anything that offensive, but Obama took the position that is taken by the neurotic, people who cannot tolerate even hearing anything that isn't 100% pure cream. I call them the all-too-clean people. I met one yesterday walking my dog. She actually stood on the sidewalk and looked down at my dog, then at me, and said "excuse me".
Most people who are not entirely neurotic say what a cute little dog. I use my dog as a litmus test and I'm not joking around either. The way people treat dogs and cats, is a key to their inner personality. I got a good look at Obama's inner child when the papers ran the photo of his daughter clinging to him while he tried to instruct her how to warm up to the dog hand picked for her by Ted Kennedy.
Obama has been making compromises since the day he was born. He was not tossed around like American kids who run and get dirty with their friends. He was raised by a neurotic family that raised him apart. Obama has no idea who he is, he's never hit the psychiatrists couch, he's never confronted his demons. He's not a decision maker. He's not a leader, he's a follower.
Where he becomes an Uncle Tom is where he volunteers to be President of the United States and asks people to put his trust in him, and then fails to represent the one group of people who needed him the most, the victims of outrageous crimes against humanity.
at 17:56 on April 18th, 2009
Great Comment Sharon. I might add I think he is no naive kid....and is either being paid off under the table by Republican Bush cohorts, or has been threatened....not to tread on the lie they built up. I too think it tells much of his character when he dumped Rev. Wright....a guy who told the truth. It befuddles me to think Obama can wear his blinders when it comes to history, and not making ammends for crimes in the past....Going up to AlbertaCowPoke..and his comment about how far back do you go with the prosecutions? I would say that he should concentrate on the present link to his administration....and when that bundle receives its Judicial Justice, then a complete past administrations stamp of review and prosecutorial process would go forward. Many lawyers are afraid to take this on...with the fear that many are dead and have gone to their grave. They fear they will become subjects of mockery, and their careers will be ruined.... Just like what Obama did when he rebuke Rev. Wright. But Rev. Wright's career is blossoming at the moment....while President Obama is sinking, as people see through his facade of lies, and snowballing friendly guy rhetoric. I know if I was President I would be reminding people of why Truman was wrong, why Eisenhower was wrong, why Kennedy was wrong, why Lyndon Johnson was wrong, why, Richard Nixon was wrong, why Jimmy Carter was wrong in starting the the Iraq Iran war, why Reagan was wrong, why Bush was wrong, and Bill Clinton, and GW Bush have had it all wrong.
He should prove he knows the difference to make change. How can he have a plank for change.....when he says nothing about where we all came from. Rev. Wright is no fool....and his sermons exemplifed what we needed to do to work away from the bad America has been engulfed with all these past years....
Obama's inability makes him nothing but a Pop Idol like the Osmonds.... bubble gum and ice cream.... Nothing wrong with that....but he needs to address the real life issues such as showing the world that we can not go on defending America and its criminal past..... There must be applied impeachment of Truman, Eisenhower, Johnson, Nixon, Carter, Reagan, GH Bush, Bill Clinton that failed....over sex...but he killed people, and GW Bush.
Truman started the chain reaction....the link that said killing innocent people is OK....and that collateral damage has no consequences. This parade of crime is handed down from one generation to the next....and someone needs to stand up there in Washington and proclaim that this will not go on.....and that all the leaders since Truman to Obama.....are held in dishonored esteem....and impeached stamped across their Adminstrational historcal crimes records..
This would be the era of the new America.....when truely America has begun, has become to find its true self and identity. From that moment the Presidental cleansing will take place....and God will shine through to bless our awakening.....
But President Obama has no inner conviction, no sense of the chain reaction of crime that has pulled America down into the cavern of hate and revenge. Perhaps he can not handle the volumes of information, the volumes of evidence that affect his own character. He either rebukes the bad, the crimes, the misery, the neglect, the stonewalling or be recognized as one of them.
At this moment I see him as one of them...not to be trusted....nothing but another lie....nothing but; as the author suggests in this article as an Uncle Tom...a stand in... to proclaim America is not a bigoted or corrupt State. I think it is rather late...It took all those years since Lincolns' ending of slavery to have a black President.... makes him more of a laughing stock....to America's historical blunders and incompetence....He needs to face truth...and exemplify its higher educational awareness.
Proud to be an American means to be able to recognize the blunders, and apply the medicine of justice on the record....that would move the crimes from past administrations...from the legitmate history books, into their rightful place in the Criminal History Books. We shall no longer live in the blurr, that doing right is to do wrong. That killing innocent people is a forgotten experience....Yet we place wreaths at Tombs of Unknown soldiers....and honor Vets who slaughtered innocent people....so we could wave flags around a Whitehouse....and proclaim how great we are as a people, and how free we are, while the dead and murdered still lie in their graves from Hiroshima, to Nagasaki, to Korea, to the villagers in Mai Lai..in Vietnam.....and in between to Kuwait, Israel, and the Millions killed in Iraq....from our doing...
No America is not great until we do this..... America is not to be trusted until we do this.....America is still a country that has not been founded....
Rev. Jermano
at 04:58 on April 19th, 2009
Rev. Jermano, I enjoyed reading your post; however, like many people and the subject of this article, your accounts of folks suffering and dying wrongly focus on people "over there." I am glad that President Obama signed to terminate torture in the War on Terror camps, although I read that is not all-inclusive. But while human rights for prisoners is riding in the front seat these days, I hope more people will take a look closer to home. Conditions in American prisons inside the U.S.A. are nearly as bad as those in the War on Terror determent camps. See for yourself at this link. (Beware - graphic violence, nudity, and death):
Torture in American Prisons
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWxpQ87C4t4
Here is what we're doing to try to channel some of the concern for prisoners homeward:
HUMAN RIGHTS FOR PRISONERS MARCH IN ATLANTA, GA ON MAY 16
http://my.nowpublic.com/world/human-rights-prisoners-march-planned-mid-may-atlanta
Last night I read part of an article published this March called China: Hundreds of Tibetan Detainees and Prisoners Unaccounted For at this link:
www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/03/09/china-hundreds-tibetan-detainees-and-prisoners-
Like Martin Luther King said, "if I lived in China or even Russia, or any totalitarian country," maybe I could understand prisoners "missing" like those in the article above. But the same thing happened to my handicapped brother right here in America, and my family has gotten the same accountability as the families of those hundreds of Tibetan detainees - NONE, despite 5.5 years of asking, "What did y'all do to Larry Neal, and why?"
Although I applaud the alarm over those men and boys who were tortured in the determent camps America ran, I hope that everyone who reads this will also give a thought to the secret prison and jail deaths and abuses of your fellow countrymen, whose families are then treated like enemies and terrorists for asking about them. Just Google "secret jail deaths," and you will see how frequently it happens, and those that you read about are only the ones that finally got reported. My brother's secret arrest and death would never have gotten reported at all had we not done it ourselves, under great censorship (which yet prevails) and threat to our safety.
Mary Neal
Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill
http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com
at 07:46 on April 19th, 2009
Dear Mary,
I might add Gerald Ford is also to be included in that list...because he is the guy who screwed up by pardoning a crook...who needed to be prosecuted. What really gets me is a pardon is suppose to be used after a prosecution, not before. How do our incompetant Officials get away with such utter lack of cognizance.
I am quite aware of the things that go on inside the USA. It is a major reason I left...to avoid the.very conceivable threat in becoming a victim as your brother did. . I am quite sorry to hear about your brother....and I really have no idea how to help you. In fact there are thousands of people who are missing people in the USA. And I do not mean to insinuate the people over there or those who lost lives outside the USA. Indeed it is as bad inside the USA. I fully agree...It is another reason why I do not support Capitol Punishment....that is the worse torture of all. I can give you assurance that God knows these things, and he is there to help us in our times of need.
Dear Lord,
Please help Mary Neal. You know Mary my fathers name was Neal. Presently I carry my mothers maiden name...because my father did not like me. He was an abusive alcoholic when I was a youngman being forced to leave home at 14 to take care of myself, because mother had 6 more mouths to feed in that old cold farm house. I do not know if we have a relation or not. In fact I never met my fathers parents or my grandparents on his side of the family. Ironically this is true....that his sister Behula Neal is the mother to the famous Comedian Drew Carey. She married to the Carey family. I met Drew when we were kids...and since then have never met again. My father passed away...and I never knew it until a vase arrived at our door in New York. I really have no idea how my father died as well. His name was Emerson Neal....aka as Whitey Neal.
God Bless Mary........may the Lord find the answers you seek.
Rev. Jermano
at 07:47 on April 19th, 2009
I just couldn't say it all but I would have liked to. I'm glad you guys said it for me. I'm 62, I paid attention to what went on in the U.S. since I could read a newspaper. I used to sit and read newspapers when I was little, so by at least high school, I was ready to roll.
When you get the combined experience of a lifetime and then stand back and look, things are obvious -- and people who can't see the obvious, then run for President and go dancing all over Washington DC putting scotch-tape on serious wounds - that person is going to hear about it.
What went on in the U.S. for the past 300 years, that's really obvious I shouldn't have to point it out. I was thinking about it again this morning because I'm working on a couple of books and re-writing in my head.
This place is a disaster area that just gets worse with every day. I think that people voted for Obama thinking he knew what a disaster area it was, and the next thing here come the J. Crew ads.