Valley Swim Club-Huntingdon Valley: Are Racism Allegations Fair?

by Tina Kells | July 9, 2009 at 02:46 pm
10886 views | 37 Recommendations | 178 comments

The sad story of the 65 kids of Creative Steps Day Camp verses racism at The Valley Swim Club may seem like something from a near century ago, but it actually happened in 2009, when the US is being led by its first African-American president.

As NowPublic editor Karen Hatter reported The Valley Swim Club in Huntingdon Valley, Pennsylvania accepted a $1900 fee from Creative Steps Day Camp only to turn 65 young kids away over a stated issue of "complexion."  The Valley Swim Club not only sent the kids away, it refunded the fee and banned the kids of Creative Steps from ever returning.

The story smacks of a kind of racism most of us would like to believe is dead in the USA, shining a bright light on the fact that racism is still alive and well.  The Valley Swim Club racism case has not gone unnoticed in Washington.  US senator Arlen Specter announced plans to launch a discrimination investigation against The Valley Swim Club.

Arlen Specter was not the only person in Pennsylvania who found what appears to be a Valley Swim Club ban on minority kids outrageous.  Local groups and businesses stepped up and expressed their disgust in a proactive way; Girard College boarding school offered their pool to the Creative Steps kids, and local ice cream parlor Gumdrops & Sprinkles gave the day camp a party of candy and ice cream making for free.

The banning has caused so much controversy that U.S. Senator Arlen Specter (D-Pa.) plans to launch an investigation into the discrimination claim.

"The allegations against the swim club as they are reported are extremely disturbing," Specter said in a statement. "I am reaching out to the parties involved to ascertain the facts. Racial discrimination has no place in America today."

A protest is planned outside the gates of the Valley Swim Club Thursday night (July 9, 2009).

An investigation into the matter may be the only way that the truth of the events can come out and The Valley Swim Club has said it will cooperate.  The Valley Swim Club has remained closed since the incident was exposed in the press and members have stepped forward to clarify the club's position.  The club has repeatedly stated that race was not a factor in the banning of the Creative Steps kids.

If the position of The Valley Swim Club is to be believed, racism was not the reason the kids were banned... it was a matter of another "ism," age-ism.  Adult members of the club, many of whom are seniors, say they objected to having large groups of children swimming at the pool regardless of their race.  Many of these members have stepped forward saying the use of the word "complexion" in the official Valley Swim Club press statement has been misunderstood.

Club members, who were at the pool on the day of the incident, came forward Thursday to defend the organization.

"This has nothing to do with race," member Lori Slowinski said. "I paid my money for a private swim club…if they're gonna have it out to camps, then I want my money back."

Jim Flynn went right to the club president after the kids took the plunge into the pool.

"I was the first person to talk to the president, because the pool was overcrowded," said Flynn. "As members we have nothing to hide. There's good people here."

Daniel Veres, a 16-year old Hispanic teen who is also a member, says the entire situtation is just a misunderstanding.

"We're not judgemental, we're just friendly," Veres said of the mostly white club.

For the children involved, the entire situation has left them simply sad and confused.


The Valley Swim Club blames a poor choice of words on the part of its representatives for the perception that race was a factor in the decision to ban the kids of Creative Steps Day Camp. For its part, The Valley Swim Club-Huntingdon Valley has unequivocally refuted all allegations of racism and has replaced its entire website with a single page statement which reads:

The Valley Club is deeply troubled by the recent allegations of racism which are completely untrue.

We had originally agreed to invite the camps to use our facility, knowing full well that the children from the camps were from multi-ethnic backgrounds. Unfortunately, we quickly learned that we underestimated the capacity of our facilities and realized that we could not accommodate the number of children from these camps. All funds were returned to the camps and we will re-evaluate the issue at a later date to determine whether it can be feasible in the future.

Our Valley Club deplores discrimination in any form, as is evidenced by our multi-ethnic and diverse membership. Whatever comments may or may not have been made by an individual member is an opinion not shared by The Valley Club Board.

What do you think? Was racism a factor or was it really a matter of adults not wanting large groups of kids at the pool?  Please comment and let us know if you believe The Valley Swim Club's hindsight explanation. 

Do you accept that the statement "There was concern that a lot of kids would change the complexion … and the atmosphere of the club" has been misunderstood due to poor word choice?  Or do you think this is all nothing more than poorly executed damage control?  Racism or no, you tell us...

recommend This comment thread is now closed
8
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

The fact that they used the word complexion is troubling.  What else could it be other than a statement of skin colour.  I think the club's representatives screwed up and now they're backpeddling.  Surely they knew how many kids were coming to start out with, after all they accepted the fees for their attendance.  I believe race played a role.

7
Tina Kells

I totally agree that the word complexion was a terrible choice and I share your skepticism.

3
Eureka The Internet

"a point of view or general attitude or inclination" is an alternate definition to complexion. I was not aware of this, and assumed the comment was based on skin color, until I used this marvelous thing called the Internet. A simple search for the definition of the word would yield these informative results. It seems that the "journalists" reporting this story could not do this and are propagating the "complexion controversy." Poor wording, yes, indicitive of racism, not with a simple addition to ones vocabulary.

5
Michele Porter

You are obviously of the preferred complexion (caucasion) and have never been subjected to racism, subtle or blatent.  Please don't throw out that tired reverse discrimination bull, if you do, then keep in mind that minorities get a taste of discrimination throughout their lifetime.

For you to infer that people who believe the word complexion had anything to do with racism are ignorant is unbelievable as well as naive.

You can not convince me or others that the yahoo who made the statement was using the word complexion in the context of  a point of view or general attitude or inclination. You had to look complexion up in order to "prove" that the statement in and of itself is not racist. If that's all you need, so be it.

Believe me, when someone calls me a nigger I know got damn well they are not using it in the context of being miserly or stingy. 

0
joslyn

do you seriously expect people to believe that BS that you tryin to dish out!!?? that is the most ignorant explanation that i have heard thus far! like that other person said, you MUST be white because only someone of the same kind as those racist bastards at that club would say such a weak cop out because no one in their right mind could have a logical explanation for what that man said. it was BLATANT racism; he can't get around that. but now he is desperately trying to take back what he said probably by having people like you write ridiculous crap like that. its an insult to my intelligence and everyone elses so i would suggest that you keep anything like that to yourself!!

0
Frankenberry

I summize that the autors of this clubs statement did not look to the internet to define their usage of this word when they used it. Hence, it was delivered as received... to convey "race". Nor did the members present requesting the expulsion look to the internet to deliver their words of hate to young children of differing skin tone... no they just dug down deep within the history of intolerance born and cultivated within their anglo ancestory to deliver the slurs that these young children had to hear. Your spin on this story bears the republican moniker and delusions.

1
Imme

Don't play that funky music white boy.

1
Laughing-Samurai
A private suburban swim club accused of racism after it canceled the memberships of dozens of minority children says it will seek a meeting with the kids' camps to work out an agreement for them to return.

Amy Goldman, a member of The Valley Club, said those able to attend a hastily called meeting Sunday afternoon voted unanimously in support of reinstating the memberships of the Creative Steps day camp and two other camps as long as safety issues, times and terms can be agreed upon.

The Creative Steps camp had arranged for 65 mostly black and Hispanic children to swim each Monday afternoon at the gated Huntingdon Valley club, which is on a leafy hillside in a village straddling two overwhelmingly white townships. But after the group arrived June 29, camp director Alethea Wright said, several children reported hearing racial comments and some swim club members pulled their children out of the pool.

"We have near-unanimous approval from our membership, so at this point we'll be figuring out ... how to approach all the camps and see how we can move forward," Duesler told WPVI-TV at the club's entrance on Sunday.

The swim club has claimed it has a diverse, multiethnic membership, but Goldman, a member for two years, said she couldn't remember seeing a black member this year.

Goldman said members were told that the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission, which has opened an investigation, is to make a fact-finding visit to the club July 30. U.S. Sen. Arlen Specter, D-Pa., said Friday he had asked the U.S. Department of Justice to investigate "to determine what action, if any, is warranted by the Civil Rights Division."

Others to criticize the club include the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and the United States' highest-profile black swimmer, Olympic gold medalist Cullen Jones, who said Thursday that "hearing about what's happened to these 65 kids is both disturbing and appalling."

Camp parent Silvia Carvalho said she hadn't heard about the club's action but didn't believe her 9-year-old daughter, Araceli, would be willing to return.

"She has already said so," Carvalho said Sunday night. "She doesn't want people to look at her the same way."
0
ShakingHeadSadly

Let's hope that if this case goes to trial that the club gets a bit more assumption of innocence than this article assumes. 

This is currently a case of "he said, she said"...and with the current PC environment in this country, it only takes the ACCUSATION to prove guilt anymore.  Let's wait for real EVIDENCE before we decide who was right and who was wrong.

9
Don Larrson

65 kids is not a lot for a pool that size.  kid's heard comments from Valley members concerning race............ kid's repeat what they heard.  maybe the racist members should be banned and forced to forfeit their membership and dues.  invite the 65 kid's back again and there will be no problem with their being in the same pool.  enough said, maybe the Valley Club should lose their pool in a lawsuit and see how high they stick up their noses then.

7
Tina Kells

I think banning the members who expressed racist sentiments to the kids is a brilliant plan.  It should be done no matter what is revealed by Senator Specter's investigation.  Good idea!

2
Jadecrystal

I absolutely agree.  The kids that were there weren't ROWDY older teens there to start trouble.  The members who were there said they were well behaved.  This is a case of racism.  It's a shame........ it should be simple, if you behave, you can stay...... If not, don't come back.

1
ifly

the pool really isnt as big as you would think.

0
dlwc731

Commenting about the size of the pool as an explaination for why this situation occured is not relative because the club was well aware of the size and complexion of the children when the contract was issued, and it should be considered a breech of contract with racism as a definite factor.

1
Jase

65 kids in the addition to the members already there is quite a lot for a pool of this size. The valley club is crowded without the addition of 65 members. I firmly believe that none of the members there are in anyway racist. This is simply a misunderstanding. The members of the valley club are not racist nor arrogant.

3
loren skyy

Buddy:

Why don't you do your research - people were overheard making statements, they took their kids out of the water. Why is it so hard to believe when only a few decades ago, good old white blooded americans would pack a picnic basket and head to the park for the day's lynching. That happened buddy. Get with the program!

0
Barbara Weatherly

Give  me a  freaking  break.   if  it  walks  like a  duck  talks  like a  duck  looks  like a  duck it is  a  duck.    Are  you that  naive?

0
Sal  Akbani

There is a saying: When you are in a hole, the first thing you should do is to stop digging.

This club will have a chance to survive and perhaps settle out of court if it admists its mistake, apologizes and bans memebers who were found to be making racial remarks.

BTW the website for this club in now down. WTF??

 

 

0
The Mad Hatter

If  this is a matter of over population of this "not as big as you think pool", why have members of the Valley Club invitied the kids back (have they added a new wing?).  I hate to group everyone at the Valley Club as a racist, but this was an racist act (h** they were kids), no matter how you sugar coat it.  How can you call the racist slur's to children a misunderstand?  I'm sure in someones (heck maybe yours) world the the use of slurs is a everyday thing, these thing were used against kids who did nothing more than show up at a pool (with the fee paid for) for a few hours of fun.  You say the the club members were "misunderstood" and that they were not "racist nor arrogant", well what would you like to call it today?

0
Imme

Hey Jase,

If the pool had reached its maximum capacity, then why is the "club" extending and invitation for the camp to return???  Hmm?  I can answer that!  Are you ready for this??  The answer is because now the world knows they are out right racists!  And now they remembered we are in the year 2009 and realized they made an oopsie!  Yep!  That's the answer. (smile)  So now, of course, it's a matter of "saving face." 

 But hey, at least their ancestors would be mighty proud of those racists...you know, the yeoman farmers.  Remember them?  The were the poor white farmers who didn't have a pot-to-piss-in (chamber pots...look it up), and were the lowest on the socio-economic totem pole.  This in turn made them suck ups to the upper class- you know...straight up butt kissers!  (Similar to what some of you do today).  At any rate, they were so low in class, they said "Hey ya'll, we need somebody else to be lower than us so we can feel better about ourselves.  So let's agree to slavery.  Then we can feel better about our miserable, uneducated (dumb-as-a-rock), poor-hygiene-having selves." 

Now when these descendants of yeoman farmers (racists in America today) see someone of another complexion contrary to their own doing better than themselves, they start hating on a sista' or brotha'.  But guess what?  The opportunity is there for them as well as it has been for my  and my fellow beautifully toasted brothers and sisters of all shades..  That means those yeoman farmer descendants who choose not to seized the blessing are lazy.  So now...whose the nigger???  By definition...your people in this case?  So sad, too bad...have a nice day!

0
Anti Don

Do- it is not a large pool and most of the kids had to be kept in the shallow water because they could not swim or had not passed deep water tests, which would be impossible given the staff the lifeguards available. These are 65 kids with no parents watching them, only the staff at the day care, which are not lifeguards.

0
jill stephens

I agree whole heartedly

7
Lyn Hamilton

"member Lori Slowinski said. "I paid my money for a private swim club…if they're gonna have it out to camps, then I want my money back." 

Oh puhleeeeze - if you don't want to 'share' your 'private' pool with kids less fortunate - put one in your back yard.  Stay home, then you won't have to associate with 'non-members.'  And you won't have to worry about the 'complexion' of the club.  Unless the staff of the swim club is dumber than dirt, they would have known how many kids there would be.  AND if they had any class at all - they would NEVER have charged them for the alleged 'privilege' of swimming.

0
Gia L.

Lyn, I agree with you 100%.  This "Lori" woman couldnt sound more racist if you paid her. 

11
Joseph Grant

As a former member of the Valley Club and a person of mixed backround, I have mixed emotions about this story. The Valley Club is located in Lower Moreland township, where less than .5 percent of the population is African American. The school district is 99 percent non African American. Im not sure if the Philmont Country Club right around the corner has any African American members similar to the Valley Club

What I can tell you is that there are definitely some people who have stereotypes and discriminate against African American. There are still some kids being raised to think prejudicially. I have experienced this growing up. People did not accept me as being white. People called me names or always asked what nationality I was.

As I became less ignorant and more cultured, I have learned to deal with racism which exists in America, especially in white enclaves like Lower Moreland township. While it is easier to say that I am italian or I don't know my true ethnicity because my dad was adopted, the fact is that it matters to a lot of people on all sides of the cultural divide. Freshman year at Drexel University my professor told me "that I was squandering an opportunity that comes to rarely to young black men."

My message to the racist and prejudcial people living in Lower Moreland and other areas across America it is you that are missing out on many wonderful things that come with diversity. You are missing out on relationships with people of all walks of life for reasons of selfishness, fear and closed-mindedness. To the kids from the day camp, if you want, you can swim at my house, I'm sure if you stand up you might be able to fit in the much smaller above ground pool in my backyard. You should live in a world where  racial prejudice does not exist, but you don't. I deal with it by considering the ignorance of the person judging me on the color of my skin and not the content of my character as Martin Luther King once said.

 

 

 

1
Tina Kells

Thank you for this comment, and for the insight into the community involved that those of us who do not live there lack.

5
John Graham

Being white I have witnessed racism toward minorities. Today it is seldom as overt as this case. People may not admit it out load as much as they use to but you know when someone is racist.

I have noticed that the people who are racist don't stop there. When no minority groups are present they start in on where you went to school, what your parents do, how much money you have, what church you go to, what political party you support. These people never stop competing, comparing, and hating. These are the root causes in my opinion. (Competing)Some people are so competitive that everything they do or have must be better than someone else. (Comparing) They can not accept people who are different from themselves. If someone if different, then something must be wrong with that person. (Hating) They are consumed by "hate", if it's not one reason it's another. Openly hating someone for their race is frowned upon in our society, but hating someone for there political beliefs is acceptable and practiced daily on talk-radio.

 

 

3
ralph1234

I grew up in Lower Moreland. The area is not racist at all . Just because there are not alot of Blacks or Hispanics doesn't make it rasicst. Anyone who CAN afford to live there can. Just because most are not  many minority only states how wealthy the area may be. My neighbor was Black & his father was a physician. I would hope he chose to live there because of the excellent schools (which are afforded because of the high real estate taxes).

2
loren skyy

And so buddy, you've spoken to all the white folks I take it? That's a real general and ignorant statement and if you were to put that in an essay for school you'd get marked down on making general unfounded statements. There is research to prove that many people everywhere have racist views and I am sure some of them live in your neighbourhood.

0
andigem

Mr. Grant,

I applaud your courage and candor to share what I'm sure are painful experiences of ingorance.  Your post expressed so elegantly...not only the value of valuing diversity, but more importantly inclusion.

Continue to live a well lived life....

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke
First Flagged at 3:27 PM, Jul 9, 2009 by Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Related Stories

Recommendations (37)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from