Vancouver's Secret $100M Loan to Olympic Developer

by Jarrett Martineau | November 7, 2008 at 08:59 am
365 views | 13 Recommendations | 4 comments

Photos

Welcome To Vancouver!

Welcome To Vancouver!

see larger image

uploaded by Sturmvogel

NowPublic will be updating this story with more information. Check back for further details. 

This will certainly add fuel to the city of Vancouver's hotly contested civic election, which will be held on November 15th.

Vision Vancouver mayoral hopeful Gregor Robertson Thursday called for an emergency council session to allow public debate on reports the city will loan $100 million to developers of the troubled Olympic Village.

He also challenged Coun. Peter Ladner, mayoral candidate for the Non-Partisan Association, to spill what he knows about the deal, apparently made at an in-camera meeting on Oct. 14.

Ladner is chairman of the city's finance committee.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
mtippett

Robertson's letter includes 5 questions for Ladner:

It is essential for Vancouver taxpayers that you immediately answer five key questions as a start:

  1. Will you support Vision Vancouver’s proposal for an emergency, open council meeting next week to have a full public report on the financial situation?
  2. Will you agree to invite Estelle Lo, the Director of Finance, to this meeting to provide her analysis on the financial implications for the City of Vancouver without prejudice to her position?
  3. When did you learn that Estelle Lo, the Director of Finance, reportedly had serious concerns about a loan to Millennium Development and when were you intending to report those concerns to the public?
  4. As Chair of Vancouver’s Finance and Budget Committee will you agree to an open and transparent process to look at the City’s financial security with regards to the Millennium Development project?
  5. And lastly, will you support Vision Vancouver’s proposal that an independent auditor, with the confidence of all councillors, conduct a proper review of the financial situation and provide independent recommendations on a sound financial way forward for the City?


0
Jason Sanders

The fact that no one is saying anything about this makes it a very weird situation.

2
jr

I heard Vision Councillor Raymond Louie and NPA's Peter Ladner talking about this issue on CKNW's Christie Clark show today.  Ladner wasn't scheduled to appear but he heard what was being said on the radio and he was madder than hell and phoned in.  The two men were both excited and talked over each other at times. 

Louie had been saying that although HE VOTED FOR the deal, he now felt that he had not been given all of the information he needed to make an informed decision.  He has since learned that Estelle Low, the City accountant, had concerns about this deal.  She was apparently not at the meeting.  There is a rumor, which Clark couldn't get confirmation on, that Low has resigned over this matter.  

Louie said that he had made requests for relevant documents on the case but he has not been given what he's requested. [Vision is the pot calling the kettle black. I'm currently writing about a case in which Vision's Eleanor Gregory -- who is very close to Vision mayoral candidate Gregor Robertson -- failed to turn over a key document that a Vancouver woman requested about her own case at the
VSB, a copy of which the VSB has already acknowledged she has a right. Vision's Andrea Reimer is implicated in secrecy and an alleged cover-up -- supported by documentation -- in this case as well, which dates back to Reimer's time on School Board.  Reimer/'s conduct contributed to the fact that there is now an Int'l Boycott of VSB diplomas.  But that's a different scandal.]

Ladner then phoned in to CKNW. He was not at his most composed; he seemed upset.  He said that Louie had been at the same meeting as him, the one in which the decision had been made, and that nothing had happened on the issue since.  His point was that Louie knew as much as he did.  But Louie retorted that being Chair of Finance, Ladner was privy to more information than he was. 

Ladner mentioned at one point that Estelle Low is currently in Hong Kong, where he said she goes at this time every year to visit her mother.  He claimed that words were being put into Low's mouth "which is scandalous in my opinion".   

It is no coincidence, Ladner noted, that at a time when Gregor Robertson's unpaid skytrain fine is front page news, Vision goes public with this issue.

Ladner was asked again by Louie if he would agree to a public meeting to bring this out into the open.  Ladner did not agree, saying that to work on this type of negotiation requires a confidential setting and that the public knows that's the way it is always done.

Shortly after the CKNW interview, there was a press conference.  It was pointed out on CKNW news that none of the Vision members who voted for that potential $100 million loan to developers showed up at the press conference to answer questions.   

 

1
C McKee

The suggestion that the current problems and loan from the City could affect the City's credit rating is just left wing silliness.   This loan is from the City's Property Endowment Fund of $2Billion.   The City has the right to tax us all to pay its debts.   The tax base backing  up the City's obligations is hundreds of Billions of dollars - to even suggest that a $100Million loan to a developer of land the City owns could affect its credit rating is absurd.   

 

The best thing that can happen with this project is for Millennium to default on its obligations.   This is leased land, if the developer does not perform the lease is cancelled. The lender, Fortress, would then lose its entire investment and the City would end up with ownership of the entire project for $100Million less what Millennium have already paid on the land lease.   Who knows - they may have already paid $130Million and the City would have the project for free and put $30Million more in the Property Endownment Fund.   This would be a huge windfall for the City, as taxpayers we should all pray that it happens.  Don't worry -  it won't.

 

 I don't think that Fortress' creditors are going to let it happen.   Fortress is the owner of Whistler Blackcomb -  its lenders stepped up last week and refinanced around $1.5 Billion of Fortress debt.   They are not going to throw away the $300 to $500Million Fortress has in the Millennium project just to let the City own it for peanuts. 

 

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

mtippett
First Flagged at 3:20 PM, Nov 7, 2008 by mtippett
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (13)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from