Was President Obama ever a victim of racial profiling?

by Rhonda J Mangus | July 27, 2009 at 07:44 am
244 views | 24 Recommendations | 7 comments

Photos

Was President Obama ever a victim of racial profiling?

Was President Obama ever a victim of racial profiling?

see larger image

uploaded by Rhonda J Mangus

Was President Obama ever a victim of racial profiling?

"Not in any major way, say those close to him, but he certainly feels there have been times he was treated differently because of his race."


However post-racial the president tries to seem, as an African-American man, he, like so many, has had his experiences where he thought he was being racially profiled. As a state senator he initiated legislation to – as he put it at the time – put “police departments on notice that they're being observed” while providing “law enforcement with the information they need to address the problems” of racial profiling, while also calling for more training of police.

A 2003 Chicago Tribune story about that effort began: “Like many African-American men, Illinois state Sen. Barack Obama (D-Chicago) suspects but cannot prove he was a victim of racial profiling when he was stopped by police for no apparent reason.”

In his 2006 book The Audacity of Hope,” the president wrote: “Although, largely through luck and circumstance, I now occupy a position that insulates me from most of the bumps and bruises that the average black man must endure I can recite the usual litany of petty slights that during my 45 years have been directed my way: security guards tailing me as I shop in department stores, white couples who toss me their car keys as I stand outside a restaurant waiting for the valet, police cars pulling me over for no apparent reason."

Continued the president: "I know what it's like to have people tell me I can't do something because of my color, and I know the bitter swill of swallowed-back anger. I know as well that Michelle and I must be continually vigilant against some of the debilitating story lines that our daughters may absorb from TV and music and friends and the streets about who the world thinks they are, and what the world imagines they should be."

Interestingly, when asked at a July 2007 debate if he was "authentically black enough," then-Sen. Obama joked,"when I'm catching a cab in Manhattan in the past, I think I've given my credentials." He then turned to the "broader issue...that is that race permeates our society."


Video at the link: Police Protocol or Racial Profiling
Also on NowPublic:

Update: Boston Globe Now Posts Redacted Revised Docket on Gates

Racial Profiling Debate Triggered by Obama comments on Prof Gates

Sgt James Crowley: Is Cop That Arrested Gates A Profiling Expert?

Obama Sympathises with Henry Louis Gates After His Arrest

Cambridge police commissioner defends officer in Gates arrest

Dr. Henry Louis Gates: Interviewed Discussing Racial Profiling

Boston Globe Scrubs Gates Arrest Report From Website

Henry Louis Gates Arrest: Charges Dropped Against Harvard Prof.

Henry Louis Gates Arrest NowPublic SCAN


recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Rhonda J Mangus

As I try to locate more information on Obama's 2003 legislation, I came across another interesting read: Barack Obama's Lost Years.

0
albertacowpoke

Thanks for this Rhonda. 

0
Rhonda J Mangus

You are very welcome, albertacowpoke! Thank you for reading, commenting, and for the recommendation!:)


2
Rhonda J Mangus

I haven't been able to locate the 2003 Legislation yet, but I think this is an interesting excerpt from the story "Barack Obama's Lost Years".

"Obama's signature crime legislation was his effort to combat alleged racial discrimination by the Illinois police. In 2003, the Defender said Obama had "made a career" out of his annual battle for a bill against racial profiling. For years, profiling legislation was bottled up by the Illinois senate's Republican leader. When senate control shifted to the Democrats in 2003, Obama's racial profiling bill finally passed-just in time to give his drive for the U.S. Senate nomination a major boost. At the time, Obama touted his profiling bill as "a model for the nation." It's also said that Obama showed a willingness to listen to police during the negotiations that led to the final bill. With the Democrats in control, however, the police had little choice but to work with Obama. As Obama himself made clear at the time, the police never abandoned their opposition to the bill.

Police doubts were entirely justified. Obama's bill is a deeply flawed example of precisely the sort of grievance-driven race-based politics that fuels legislation on affirmative action and minority set-asides. All of these "remedies" falsely leap from statistical evidence of racial disparities to claims of discrimination. In the case of racial profiling, disproportionate police stops of black or Hispanic motorists in no way prove discrimination.

In her path-breaking 2001 study, "The Myth of Racial Profiling," Heather Mac Donald assembled the evidence. It showed that racially disparate patterns of drug-interdiction stops in New Jersey, one of the first states supposedly proven to have practiced racial profiling, in fact reflected racial differences in the transport of drugs. Drug trafficking is not evenly spread across the population (as profiling activists improperly assume), and for the most part New Jersey police were simply going where the drugs were. Wrote Mac Donald, "When white club owners, along with Israelis and Russians, dominated the Ecstasy trade, that's whom the cops were arresting." When the big shipments shifted to minority neighborhoods, arrests followed. That's good crime intelligence, not racism. The reason virtually every major law-enforcement organization opposes racial-profiling legislation is that these bills invariably fail to provide benchmarks based on actual group-based variations in crime rates. Without such benchmarks, there is no basis for leaping from statistical disparities in traffic-stops to accusations of police racism.

Obama's February 16, 2000, Hyde Park Herald column was a textbook example of the racial-profiling fallacies Mac Donald exposed. Arguing for legislation to require the collection of traffic-stop data by race, Obama made the bogus leap from disproportionate traffic-stops and searches to accusations of racism using the same, baseline-free ACLU-supplied statistics Mac Donald critiqued. Obama then made a still greater leap: "Racial profiling may explain why incarceration rates are so high among young African Americans-law enforcement officials may be targeting blacks and other minorities as potential criminals and are using the Vehicle Code as a tool to stop and search them." The notion that the high black incarceration rates are due to racist traffic stops is utterly fanciful. (Mac Donald lays out the evidence not only in her profiling piece, but also in a second important study, published this year, "Is the Criminal-Justice System Racist?") Obama's column takes a leaf right out of Jeremiah Wright's playbook, stoking the worst sort of race-based conspiracy theories.

Indeed, Obama's racial profiling crusade shows his political alliance with Wright, Pfleger, and Meeks in action. We know from Obama's 1988 "Why Organize?" essay that a long-term goal of his was to politically organize "liberationist" black churches:

Nowhere is the promise of organizing more apparent than in the traditional black churches. Possessing tremendous financial resources, membership, and-most important-values and biblical traditions that call for empowerment and liberation, the black church is clearly a slumbering giant in the political and economic landscape of cities like Chicago."

1
158

Most people in the US face racism at some time and black people face racism more than

others but he benefited from his color in 2008.Does anyone think a white senator from Chicago with two years service would have been elected or even nominated.


0
QueensHart

This is information a lot of people know but won't talk about because of their sensitivity . 

 Political correctness has become so absurd now that many are  "fed up". 

 Look where we are now as a country with a  real  Shyster in charge until he implodes or another election will take him out.

  Hopefully we can keep revealing the level of corruption that is in ACORN ..etc.  O has

already made some huge mistakes and I find comfort in knowing there are some honest

people still left in both parties..

Rhonda  a very good piece!

 

0
Barry Artiste

I am sure he was, though perhaps as a child of a single parent, he may have suffered those taunts as well not having  a dad present at events such as father and son outings.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Paschen
First Flagged at 8:38 AM, Jul 27, 2009 by Paschen
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (24)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from