What Democracy? Harper to Stack Senate Seats With Tory Loyalists

by Tina Kells | December 11, 2008 at 10:39 am
321 views | 17 Recommendations | 8 comments

Videos

Rick Mercer: Rick's Rant: Harper's Moves

see larger video

sourced by Tina Kells

Rick Mercer: Rick's Rant: Harper's Moves

Photos

Stephane Dion

Stephane Dion

see larger image

uploaded by Medmoiselle T

First Stephen Harper gets a figurehead Governor-General to enforce an unprecedented prorogue on Parliament and now he has vowed to fill 18 vacant Senate seats before Christmas

All the while his party is holding fast to the outright lie that a Coalition Government would be an "unelected" government.  Maybe Harper and the Conservatives need a crash course in the basics of Canadian democracy.

One of the most frustrating things about the Conservative campaign against a coalition government is the persistent assertion, and outright lie, that an opposition alliance would be an "unelected" government and that the chosen coalition leader would be an "unelected" Prime Minister.

Quote

It would be irresponsible to have this unelected coalition government stack the Senate with their supporters.
Unnamed Conservative Party Insider

Here is the reality; every member of any coalition government was elected by Canadians somewhere, and contrary to what Harper and the Tories want Canadians to believe, NOBODY except the people in Harper's riding of  Calgary Southwest, voted for him directly.

Stephen Harper is only Prime Minister because his party has the most seats in Parliament.  The Conservative Party did not win a majority of the seats in the House of Commons meaning that contrary to the current party line, the Tories do not have the majority of Canadian support.  This is why we have a "minority government" and this is why the elected members of the opposition parties are able to band together to form a coalition government.


We now are a nation run by Order in Council from the Federal Conservative Cabinet table. Democracy has been set aside in the Dominion of Canada. The voice of 62% of Canadians is no longer heard. We have a functioning arrangement where representatives of 36% of the people are running the nation - with no public scrutiny.


In Canada we do not elect our Prime Minister; the party faithful choose a party leader and the leader of the party with the most support in Parliament becomes Prime Minister.  In a majority government the Party leader with the most support is a given, but in a minority government it is up for debate.

In a minority government if the leader of the party with the most seats (not to be confused with a majority of the seats) can not get enough support from the opposition parties to pass legislation it is known as a "non-confidence" position, and that leader can no longer be Prime Minister.  In Canadian democracy non-confidence can only result in one of two things; an election or a coalition government

The Tories have spent a great deal of effort pandering to the lack of understanding that many Canadians have of their own political system.  That is a shocking abuse of public trust and Stephen Harper should be ashamed.  The only Canadians who chose Harper for Prime Minister are the Conservative Party faithful who elected him leader and the electors in his riding of Calgary Southwest who voted for him. Not a single Canadian outside of those two groups voted for him directly.

All the other party leaders currently sitting in Parliament, including the now removed Liberal leader Stephane Dion and his newly appointed successor Micheal Ignatieff, were elected in the exact same fashion.  In Canadian democracy any party leader who is able to gain the support, or confidence, of the majority of the MPs in Parliament is an elected leader and it is time that the Conservatives stopped stating otherwise. 
"In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act." - (George Orwell).


In a minority government situation the parties must work together to rule; a formal coalition is simply an agreement in kind to work together as one party until the next election is called.  A coalition is not an unelected government, it is not illegal, and it is not undemocratic (at least not in the Canadian sense of the word).  In Canada a coalition government is democracy at work.

There have been many questions raised however, about the democracy of having a Governor-General who is only intended to act as a figurehead, call a halt to Parliament via an unprecedented prorogue. And what is definitely undemocratic is a holiday rush to appoint Conservative Loyalists to an unelected Senate, which is what Stephen Harper has pledged to do.  So much for the Conservative Party of Canada as vanguards of democracy!

Prime Minister Stephen Harper plans to fill 18 vacancies in the unelected Senate with Conservative loyalists before Christmas, CTV News has learned.

Sources said Harper is concerned the Senate committee system isn't working properly because there are only 20 Conservative senators sitting in the Liberal-dominated Red Chamber.

But according to insiders, what really drove Harper to move quickly and fill the vacant Senate seats is the possibility of losing political power in January at the hands of the Liberal-NDP coalition.
recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
sara star

I find it frustrating that the minority of the seats were able to shut down the Hill. I thought majority ruled. The GG appointed by Harper should not be given this power.

I hope democracy wins at the end. Well written Tina.

0
Tina Kells

Thanks!  I agree... this is NOT democracy.  The most shocking thing about all of this for me has been the way it has exposed just how little Canadians seem to know about their own electoral system. 

0
leftdog

Great post ... Thanks! ... Luv you blogsite!!

1
mofiac

 “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”

 Dr. Paul Joseph Goebbels, leader of the Nazi Party's propaganda unit.

1
mofiac

 “I think there is a good reason why the propaganda system works that way. It recognizes that the public will not support the actual policies. Therefore it is important to prevent any knowledge or understanding of them.”


Avram Noam Chomsky, American Linguist

0
Paschen

Democracy does not really exist though in North America, yes there are democratic tendencies and ambitions however the democracy remains with a minority of people it is not a peoples democracy. The Liberal do it when there are in power and the Tories do it when ever it is there turn, in fact it is absurd as a power game and counter productive for the country it self. Canada needs to reform its democracy and establish a constitution for all Canadians. Canada does also need to rid it self of the Monarchy.

0
lefty_liberated

"In Canada we do not elect our Prime Minister; the party faithful choose a party leader and the leader of the party with the most support in Parliament becomes Prime Minister."
Holy Crap!!?!

0
Barbara McPherson

It's great that people are finally waking up to their responsibilies in our democracy.  Let's not accuse the Tories of wrecking democracy.  The Senate is too short of senators for it to function properly.  The Tory senators, if they are appointed, must agree to stand for election if Senate reform comes about.  If all 18 vacant seats were filled with Tories, there would still be a Liberal majority in the Senate.  Have a healthy skepticism of all pronouncements by all politicians, whatever their stripe.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

sara star
First Flagged at 10:49 AM, Dec 11, 2008 by sara star
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (17)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from