NP Rank:
Xenophobes beware, more immigrants are coming!
Xenophobes beware, more immigrants are coming!
Racists and xenophobes, start your computers: The immigrants are coming, the immigrants are coming!
Oh, sorry, I'd better define that second term: A xenophobe is someone who hates foreigners and foreignness.
Those of you who are both xenophobic and racist can get your bile up over the fact that not only are these immigrants foreign, most of them aren't even white!
Statistics Canada has just released data showing B.C. has been hit with the biggest wave of immigrants in more than a decade:13,218 of them landed in B.C. between July and September, the largest number in any three-month period since 1997.
Ethan Baron spent four years as a general-assignment reporter at The Province before taking on the job of columnist in 2009. He has worked as one sort of journalist or another for more than 15 years, in the U.S. and Canada, after receiving a master's degree in journalism from the University of California, Berkeley. Covering all manner of stories, his work has taken him to crime scenes, courtrooms, carnivals and war zones, with occasional stops at crack houses and grandmothers' kitchens.
By Ethan Baron (The Province)
The story above by The Province journalist Ethan Baron raised many questions.
Legitimate Immigrants soon to become Canadian citizens, many making Vancouver their home has this Vancouver quasi photographer/journalist on a rant.
British Columbia’s Liberal government under Gordon Campbell, whose recent resignation has seen many dancing in the streets, seems to have done more to bring legitimate immigrants to our province than the NDP and SoCreds combined.
While blaming the Canadian government for distributing immigrant funding equitably to immigration community groups across Canada seems fiscally responsible, charges of racism against the government are unfounded.
Ethan Baron, pursed lips at the ready, seems to be either directing his rant against British Columbians or towards Stephen Harper, Prime Minister of Canada, perhaps both.
Racism or self preservation
Perhaps Ethan Baron misdirected hissy fit against British Columbians as racist may not be without merit, though perhaps confusing racism with Canadians self economic preservation.
While some British Columbia may be clad in white pointy hats, the majority of British Columbians were fueled by outrage towards those who illegal immigrants who continually jump ahead of the immigration line by way of boat, thus scamming Canada’s generosity, and depriving the legitimate refugee their turn at a better life, this could amount to a sort of genocide against legitimate immigrants whose own self preservation may not fall under refugee status, but for one reason or another their life may be currently in danger in their own country, especially those fleeing religious or gay persecution.
Is it racism exacerbated when even legitimate immigrants witness illegal immigrants with $50,000 dollars for a boat ticket enjoy what legitimate immigrants do not, such as not having an immediate debt of $5,000.00 to pay back the Canadian government for their airfare to get to Canada.
Rumour and Innuendo
It has been rumoured that business class immigrants and the Vancouver real estate market are tied to prerequisite token amount investor immigrants must bring to the British Columbia economy. It certainly seems that when an immigrant of means comes to Vancouver, realtors know a good thing when they see it when Canada requires Investor immigrants to pony up $1.6 million dollars, with $800,000 dollars to go to the province for business investment. So it is a win-win situation for the province in their quest to get as many immigrant investors into Metro Vancouver. The immigrant investor will get that $800,000 dollars back in about 5 years, without interest.
Since the immigrant investor program began the base amounts required for investment immigrants to bring to Canada seemed to coincide with Metro Vancouver house prices matching investor wealth beginning in the mid 1980s. The year 2010 saw $1.6 million as a base immigration to Canada criteria, with $800,000 dollars for the province to invest and $800,000 dollars left over for the new arrival to purchase a modest home. Currently a modest home in Metro Vancouver is priced around $800,000 dollars. In 2009, investor immigrants were required to have $1 million dollars, with $500,000 for provincial investment, leaving the immigrant investor $500,000 dollars to buy a home. Guess what the house prices were then? Going back to Expo one can see the house prices versus immigrant investor ratio. Is it any wonder the majority of politicians were realtors or land speculators, developers and property investors? Rumour and innuendo? You decide!
Facts and Figures
Currently Canada will accept upwards of 250,000 immigrants in 2011 alone, with successive arrivals of 250,000 each year after that to infinity.
Canadian taxpayers are aware that immigrant settlement allowances of $1,200.00 per month, including other benefits Canadians enjoy is certainly not a princely sum and well below the poverty line.
Considering there are Canadians who are also trying to raise a family on a similar amount, many Canadians below the poverty line feel hard done by, thus self preservation kicks in when they perceive newcomers getting a better deal, no matter how small. This is not even placing the homeless who walk our streets into the equation who continually do without.
Monthly payouts to new immigrants just in 2010 alone with other social services tabulated, amounts to $500 million dollars each and every month.
Canada’s population currently at around 32 million citizens has a median age of 39 years of age. Canada has approximately 16 million Canadians currently employed; this includes part time students over the age of 15.
A reality check!
The Canadian taxpayer is on the hook for $300.00 a year and that is a conservative amount totaling $4.5 Billion dollars a year. This amount will double when compounded each and every year as another 250,000 new arrivals seek Canada as their home. This payout compounded annually for new immigrants will last for an average term of two years or $9 Billion dollars, replacing the previous wave of new arrivals each year.
While the $1,200.00 monthly stipend for new immigrants will continue for two years, it will cease once new immigrant are ready for the dwindling Mcjob market, joining Canadians who can’t find one.
While some immigrants will arrive up and running if they speak either of Canada’s official language, the majority of new Canadians will require language training which can take up to two years in order to even qualify to get into the Canadian job market.
Media reports that thousands and thousands of skilled immigrants many with doctorates are stonewalled in getting jobs within their profession, while delivering pizzas or driving taxis to support their families.
So if Canada’s intent is get as many immigrants who are skilled doctors, accountants, scientists, carpenters etc into Canada to provide a boost to a much needed labour force fails miserably. How could Canada say one thing and yet do another? Certainly looking for a potential 250,000 ethnic voters to prop up their political party fortunes comes to mind.
Government cuts to social programs
British Columbians are outraged by Government deep cuts to social services, everything from Health Care, Schools, Welfare and Unemployment etc.
The British Columbia government excuse is we cannot afford to continue to pay for the increase use by British Columbia taxpayers use of these services. Yet all the while BC politicians spout that increasing immigration to British Columbia brings money, jobs and prosperity. Apparently not!
If British Columbian tax dollars are not meeting the costs associated with the increase use of these services, yet at the same time British Columbians do not want to pay more taxes to support these services, where should our priorities lie to pay for these programs?
Some politicians and labour groups insist raising the minimum wage from $8.00 anywhere from $10.00 to $15.00 dollars an hour is the answer to what ails us. Somehow I don’t think the immigrant entrepreneur would like that, considering his hard earned money and little profit he invests in a business in British Columbia would evaporate exponentially and he would look to greener pastures elsewhere in Canada, thus leaving British Columbia with additional economic immigrants with little work or language skills.
The children are our future
It is believed Canada hedges it hopes not with the parents, but with the children who will be the main economic contributors as Canadians. It is reported that in British Columbia alone the BC government closed 176 schools, with many more threatened with impending closures.
To put things into perspective, if Canada hedges its bets on the children of immigrants, does it make sense for schools to close, not including school closures Canada wide? I think not, especially if our motive is to educate new Canadians for the job market.
Teachers, teach, developing young minds, but to teach in an amphitheatre setting devoid students of any chance of one to one contact with their academic mentor who will ultimately determine their path both mentally and socially in life.
Reducing teachers, eliminating schools, increasing class sizes shows the government once again is not serious in developing young minds as our future workforce, unless that workforce are destined to wear a paper hat and dole out supersized meals.
Immigrant parents who either are unskilled or lack the education or language skills to help their child with their studies will doom their child to fail.
Certainly with school overcrowding, students seem to be regaled to educational institutions similar to cattle pens. School overcrowding so immense that if our children were chickens, would have PETA and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency coming down hard with a vengeance.
So increasing immigration may not be the answer until we solve the dilemma what is our future workforce today. Education is the key, not numbers. To do otherwise may see Canada as a future population of illiterates without any meaningful skills.
In ending
Call it racism or call it economic self preservation, bottom line, Canadians and immigrants alike are getting the big political reach around, financially and emotionally.
As for our new Canadians, welcome to Canada, welcome to your new economic nightmare as politicians, especially the New Democratic Party and Liberal Party who will continually state we need more immigrants, yet once you become Canadian you no longer qualify as an immigrant and will join the ranks of the ignored who complain as a Canadian and will be called a racist because you too will be clamoring for too few jobs and experience the joy of frustration of trying to access dwindling social services, just like the rest of us.
As for Ethan Baron, you are way off the mark, you should stick to what you know best, for the life of me I am not sure what that would be, but I am sure if you asked any Grandma who subsists under the poverty line her views on this story, you would deem her a racist too.



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (4)
- Sign In or Join to post comments
"thirty-aught-six" (not verified)at 11:53 on December 27th, 2010
Canadian friends tell me the current welfare base is approx. $500.00/mth. The immigrant seems to get preferential financial treatment not credited to the disenfranchised citizen.
at 17:02 on December 28th, 2010
Thanks for the comment 30-06 but the government states as do new arrivals and other social agencies the monthly stipend is $1200.00 a month. While a single Canadian man or woman on welfare gets around $630.00 a month
at 09:20 on December 31st, 2010
Definitely food for thought here, Rory. But, for the sake of playing Devils Advocate, I would just point out that A) not all of those immigrants are entitled to that full $1200, as many immigrants arrive in Canada ready, willing, and able to work, or “immigrate” having already been working here for many years. And B) while it is true that welfare from the provincial government is not only a trifling amount, but also extremely embarrassing to apply for, and still surrounded in stigma within our society, Employment Insurance, for those who qualify, is something in the region of $450 a week for most people. It is an unfortunate fact, of course, that the job market is not in a condition these days where people can find a new job as quickly as in previous years, and $450 is no princely sum, but it works out to more than 23,000 a year, which may not keep you living in luxury, but it is usually enough to keep you off the streets. As a temporary stop gap in earnings, I’d say EI is a better deal, by-and-large, than the stipend.
A big reason that immigrants get jobs, while many Canadians do not is also the fact that, in many cases, the employer prefers it. I have worked in jobs where they prefer to hire someone on a work permit, because they can pay them less, and as a new-comer, they do not know their rights here in <?xml:namespace prefix = st1 />Canada. The worse their English, the better a candidate for the job they are, because even when they learn their rights, they will have a terrible time trying to file a complaint if they do not speak one of the official languages. Also, I have met a lot of people on working visas, mostly from Australia, who take a job in Canada working for an employer who tells them they do not need a Social Insurance Number, but they DO need to surrender their passport. The kids work for often less than minimum wage, with no basic rights, and have “deductions” made off their pay for “BC Income Tax” Canada Pension Plan and EI, as well as Federal Income tax, that eat up most of their pay. When they start asking questions they are fired or laid off, their passports have conveniently been “lost” along with their working visas, and they are now stuck, unemployed, unemployable, and with no immediate recourse because they do not have a SIN and can’t actually apply for EI or Welfare, or anything else, since they have not paid taxes or anything else, because the employer has been pocketing their “deductions.” Also, I am curious, as an aside, who is included in that figure of annual immigrants to Canada? I am certain it includes a large number of children, but does it also include the people on Work Visas, who clear through immigration to be allowed into the country for six months to learn English, and work at Tim Horton’s? While it is true that some of the temporary workers will get a renewal, and stay in the country for longer, many are here for only a short time, and then they move on. The Australians in Whistler, or Banff, for example, may come back down the road, but they are really only here for the Ski season, and to have a good time. There are dozens of Language schools in the downtown Vancouver area alone, some legitimate some not; they are full of temporary residents, on student visas. Young kids, most of them just out of high school, flood into Vancouver on a daily basis, but they have no intention of staying, working, or collecting money from the government, in fact, before coming on a temporary visa, most are required to show they have the financial resources to support themselves before getting here. They only come for a short period, and then they move on, home or to the next country, seeing the world.Immigration and the economy are two major issues our country is facing these days. In BC, however, the two are only related thanks to years of provincial mismanagement, making employees have very little rights, and almost no recourse against crooked employers, who have more to gain by hiring new immigrants who cannot stand up for themselves. It is a sad state of affairs, and one that needs dealt with. It is also time that some of those immigrants who have been victimized by crooked employers or language schools have some more rights and recourse. I am sure if it was harder to bring a teenager from Australia or England over to work for peanuts than to hire a local to work for a livable wage, we would see an improvement on both issues; the new BC government, whoever it will be, and whenever it will come in to being, will have to take a more proactive role to make it happen, though.
at 13:21 on January 13th, 2011
Anyone who dares question mass immigration policies lobbied by big corporations in order to increase the demand for jobs and lower salaries is a racist.
Why? Because Ethan Baron said so! Mass Immigration and multiculturalism is a fact that has never been debated or disputed in Canada (outside of Quebec) because we have to deal with the hackneyed and dishonest tactics of the PC police dear to intellectual terrorists and which consist of spewing accusations of racism to all those who may disagree with them, and this, without the shadow of a justification - just like a weapon cutting off any form of democratic debate. We thought we understood that we had to be careful of ideologies even if they sound generous, because on the road of goodness we always end up seeing a gulag or a concentration camp. Did the western world lefties forget what history taught us? Multiculturalism is the new religion of mankind which in its turn becomes a new form of tyranny. Multiculturalist ideologues like Ethan Baron confine reality within a simplistic conflict of attackers and victims; creating reversals (where Jews become Nazis and the U.S.A and Canada totalitarian countries) the hate of multiculturalists like Mr. Baron is as dangerous as the hate of cross-burning racists.