NP Rank:
YES! More Troops For Iraq :: MAXINE
It is always confusing for a politically charged, micro-management focused, uninformed populous to rile against what a war power professional may recognize as the right thing to do at a time of conflict ... but, YES, more troops for Iraq.
General Petreaus was approved by unanimous vote by the Senate because it was the right thing to do - and now HE wants more troops because it IS the right thing to do.
The one thing that we have learned as it relates to task competency is that one leaves the decision making of each task to the trained professionals.
MAXINE has one question - When you have a pain in your jaw coming from a cracked tooth, which do you want to work on it ... Senator Kennedy, Senator Clinton ... Any Senator, or a trained and proven dentist with a going practice?
Give the General his request and let him run the war, thank you!
" Any time you deploy more combat forces you need more support forces," said Michael O'Hanlon , a defense specialist at the Brookings Institution who compiles the Iraq Index. "You need some tactical mobility to get them out of trouble."
Crowd Power
-
Edmund Jenks
Los Angeles, California, United States




Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (2)
at 17:30 on March 17th, 2007
Only problem is, the "war" has no victory scenario. As such, the troops' (now in greater numbers) only achievable mission is to stay alive. Kinda like Vietnam.
at 17:49 on March 17th, 2007
In Viet Nam, there had been no elections (three in Iraq to form a government).
Viet Nam is not the scenario for comparison - this scenario should be compared to any world war.
QUESTION:
Have our troops ever left Japan, Germany, heck - even Korea?
NO! - so this is not the measure ... if troops leave. The measure is are the people of Iraq able to pursue their freely elected lives in an atmosphere of relative safety and success.
Micro management will not work. Turning our back on a peoples who have violent and horrific tendencies will not work either.
For now, at least, there is a general who is having success at leading - Let HIM lead and give him the tools to lead.
Thanks for the comment.